We return to chat about The Lord of The Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 Episodes 3 and 4. We will be spoiling everything up to the end of episode 4 in this discussion.
Our Rings of Power Season 3 podcast is Dedicated to the memory of our beloved Dorothy Harrison who passed away this year.
The Rings Of Power Season 3 Episode 3 and 4 Details
Season 3 Episode 3 "The Secret Fire"
Episode Written by J. D. Payne and Patrick McKay
Episode Directed by Sanaa Hamri
Season 3 Episode 4 “Gundabad”
Episode directed by Charlotte Brändström
Episode written by Justin Doble
Based on "The Lord of the Rings" and appendices by J.R.R. Tolkien
Episode 3 "The Secret Fire" Synopsis
In Rhûn, Khamûl uses his ring to usurp the Dark Wizard's authority, gaining control over the Gaudrim and Mystics. Khamûl blackmails the Dark Wizard into allying Rhûn's forces with Sauron.
Gandalf and Tom Bombadil infiltrate the Dark Wizard's fortress but disagree on whether to fight the Dark Wizard. After experiencing a vision of the Secret Fire, Gandalf learns that the Dark Wizard is the Istari Pallando, who murdered his companion Alatar, turning Rhûn into a barren desert. After receiving orders to save Pallando, Gandalf returns to Tom's hut but finds he has left Rhûn.
Elsewhere, Galadriel travels with Arondir and the captive Marnûkh towards the Orc prison of Gundabad, intending to rescue an imprisoned Elven smith named Maitalle from Eregion.
Separately, Sauron tortures two Elven captives and learns that an Elven smith survived the battle of Eregion and duduces they are held at Gundabad.
At the Faithful haven in western Numenor, Elendil and his son Anárion hunt for a spy among their ranks. However, Elendil is captured in a sting operation by Kemen. Anárion fights the King's men but is unable to stop them from extracting his father.
Episode 4 “Gundabad” Synopsis
Marnûkh brings Galadriel and Arondir into Gundabad, disguised as his prisoners. While searching for Maitalle (who is deceased), Marnûkh and Arondir encounter Galadriel's lost lover Celeborn and free him.
Before they can escape with Galadriel, Sauron arrives on a fell beast with his Nazgnagôl. Marnûkh stages a prison break but is killed by Theo, who has become a Nazgnagôl. Arondir tries to reason with Theo but is killed by his former friend. Galadriel and Celeborn escape with the help of Landroval Prince of the giant eagles.
Meanwhile in Khazad-dûm, Thrain challenges King Durin's claim to the throne on the grounds that their late father Durin III was of unsound mind while wearing a Ring of Power. During a ritualistic duel, Durin's hot headedness gets the better of him after his teenage son reveals that Thrain purportedly had an affair with his mother Disa. Thrain wins the duel and the throne.
Elsewhere in Numenor, Anárion and Faithful soldiers rescue his father Elendil and capture Kemen.
Where can I send Feedback for The Rings of Power Season 3?
Once you've watched the episodes you can email us to feedback@tvpodcastindustries.com, you can message us @TVPodIndustries on Threads or join our Facebook group at https://facebook.com/groups/tvpodcastindustries or join us on our Discord server at https://discord.gg/DyVtkuuWZP and share your thoughts in our spoiler posts for each episode.
Made Possible with Patreon
TV Podcast Industries is made possible by our supporters on Patreon. You can follow and support us here: https://www.patreon.com/tvpodcastindustries
Next Time On TV Podcast Industries...
Thanks for joining us for our podcast all about The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 Episodes 3 and 4. We will be back next time with our podcast all about The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 5 "The Lady of Lórien" and Episode 6 "From Valinor" which are both available on Prime Video.
Thanks so much for joining our circle fellow Ringers we hope to see you again soon.
Keep watching, Keep Listening and Keep sailing for The West.
John, and Derek
TV Podcast Industries
All images and audio clips are copyright of Prime Video and their respective copyright owners. The intro music for our Rings of Power Podcast is an edit of Humanity and our outro is an edit of Cinematic Trailer both by Scott Holmes Music and used under Creative Commons attribution 4.0 license
[00:00:00] This is the Rings of Power Podcast on TV Podcast Industries and we're talking about The Rings of Power Season 3, Episode 3, The Secret Fire and Episode 4, Gundabad We're leaving this place together I said go! Take off the ring He's coming
[00:00:27] I left you once before Theo, I will not do it again Let me help you
[00:01:14] Kill him
[00:02:01] Welcome back fellow ringers This is the Rings of Power Podcast on TV Podcast Industries and we're looking at Episode 3 and 4 of The Rings of Power from this season, Season 3 Episode 3 is called The Secret Fire and Episode 4 is Gundabad Everything is not so wunderbar in Gundabad after all, certainly not after this one
[00:02:31] Especially with the death of such a big character in the fourth episode, but I am one of your hosts John I am your other host Derek watching through weeping eyes for this episode, yeah, very tearful I know It's a sad one, great, fantastic, but very sad Great drama Yes, loved it Loved it Yes, great drama
[00:02:59] But, yes, let us get into our spoiler-filled discussion of these two episodes of The Rings of Power Just quickly before we do, remember fellow ringers, you can head on over to tvpodcastindustries.com where you can subscribe to the podcast on any ring-bearing or ring-wraithing podcast player of your choice You can also leave a voicemail for our feedback section
[00:03:22] You can send in emails to feedback at tvpodcastindustries.com as well for our feedback section And, of course, we do have our Facebook group over on facebook.com forward slash groups forward slash tvpodcastindustries Absolutely We also have our Discord available, the details of which are in our show notes right here Because of the very odd nature of how these episodes are being released, there's feedback coming in all over the place from loads of different episodes at different times
[00:03:51] So we'll talk all about the feedback in the episodes as we record them Do you know how much weirder it's getting, John? We had the first four episodes released in a week Then two more came out today as we're recording these podcasts The seventh episode, the penultimate episode of the show, is being released in cinemas next Monday Just for the laugh Not the two episodes, just the seventh episode And then the final two episodes will be available in Prime Video the following Wednesday So just for laugh So seven and eight will be
[00:04:18] Will come out on the two days after the episode seven comes out in the cinema You know, why not try something else? See if we can project it on the sphere in Las Vegas And episode eight will come out in 2032 Crazy stuff But they're trying everything You know, as we mentioned last week We're not going to talk about it again But as we mentioned last week No streaming service has any idea how to release stuff And we're already behind schedule Yeah As the fifth and sixth episodes come out We are podcasting about episodes three and four
[00:04:48] So hopefully, fellow ringers You're liking our more leisurely pace With the podcasts You see, Leslie, there's still two episodes this week Two episodes last week And we did Vision Quest last week as well That is true We are recording these for whenever you get around to listen Yes So not everybody's going to get the time to listen in between watching the shows Because there's a lot of stuff to watch as well So hopefully, we're catching up with you in the year 2075 And you're catching up on all of the rings of power Exactly
[00:05:18] And you may suddenly realize Oh look, I can pop in and watch it in the cinema for episode seven I guess that's just in the US though No, it's in our local cinema around the corner on next Monday At 7.45 we could walk around the corner and see on the big screen I think we should I think we should I think we should It's only eight bucks as well They're not doing the expensive seats on it It's the cheap money Maybe they come with a popcorn holder Maybe it's a ring wraith I don't think they're going to do popcorn buckets for this one unfortunately
[00:05:47] But maybe when Lord of the Rings gets re-released in IMAX in a couple of years They'll have popcorn buckets I think Warner Brothers are missing a trick there if they don't do that I think so I think so Anyway, fellow ringers Let us get into our spoiler-filled discussion Derek, give us some of the episode details Absolutely The show, of course, is based on the Lord of the Rings and the appendices by J.R. Tolkien The showrunners for the show are J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay
[00:06:16] Who were the showrunners for the previous two seasons as well Executive producer for the show are Lindsay Webber, Justin Doble, Charlotte Brandstrom and Kate Hazel With co-producer Andrew Lee Episode 3 and 4 were directed by Sana Hanmery Who directed loads of episodes over the course of the last couple of seasons of The Rings of Power Including the big Ent episode last season So yeah, back again to direct two epic episodes of the season Episode 3 was written by J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay, the two showrunners
[00:06:44] And episode 4 was written by Justin Doble who wrote last week's episode 2 as well John, do you want to give us the synopsis for episode 3, The Secret Fire and episode 4, Gundabad? Sure In Rune, Camul uses his ring to usurp the Dark Wizard's authority Gaining control over the Gaudrum and Mystics Camul blackmails the Dark Wizard into allying Rune's forces with Sauron
[00:07:11] Gandalf and Tom Bombadil infiltrate the Dark Wizard's fortress But disagree on whether to fight the Dark Wizard After experiencing a vision of the secret fire Gandalf learns that the Dark Wizard is the Astari Pallando Who murdered his companion, Alatar Turning Rune into a barren desert After receiving orders to save Pallando Gandalf returns to Tom's hut But finds he has left Rune Elsewhere, Gladril travels with Arondir
[00:07:39] And the captive Marnuk Towards the Orc prison of Gundabad Intending to rescue an imprisoned Elven smith named Maitali from Eragon Separately, Sauron tortures two Elven captors And learns that an Elven smith survived the Battle of Oregion And deduces they are held at Gundabad Meanwhile, in Numenor, at the faithful Haven in the West Elendil and his son Anárion hunt for a spy among their ranks
[00:08:07] However, Elendil is captured in a sting operation by Kemen Anarion fights the king's men But is unable to stop them from extracting his father But luckily, we have episode 4 Just around the corner, John In episode 4, Marnuk brings Gladril and Arondir into Gundabad Disguised as his prisoners While searching for Maitali, who is deceased
[00:08:33] Marnuk and Arondir encounter Gladril's lost lover, Celeborn And free him Before they can escape with Gladril Sauron arrives on a fel beast With his Naznagul Marnuk stages a prison break But is killed by Theo Who has become a Naznagul Arondir tries to reason with Theo But is killed by his former friend Gladril and Celeborn escape With the help of Landraval Prince of the Eagles Meanwhile in Khazad-dûm
[00:09:03] Thrain challenges King Durin's claim to the throne On the grounds that their late father Durin III Was of unsound mind while wearing a ring of power During a ritualistic duel Durin's hot-headedness gets the better of him After his teenage son reveals that Thrain purportedly had an affair With his mother Diza Thrain wins the duel and the throne Elsewhere in Numenor Anarion and faithful soldiers Rescue his father Elendil
[00:09:32] And capture Kemmen Twist in the tale? Yes, the rotter Kemmen The rotter Yeah That was so back and forth That it was basically just the two of them had a chat in the back of a van But it ended up Everybody changed positions That's kind of it But we'll get into discussing everything The oldie police van Well, yeah, yeah, exactly Carriage Carriage But let's discuss our tales of Middle-earth, John Indeed
[00:10:02] Our big moments from the episode Yes, let us get into tale number one Gandalf's purpose Finally Yes Look, it took two whole seasons to get his name So I'm glad in the third episode of the series They gave him a purpose this quickly It's also really important, you know, we were talking last week About why did they release four episodes in one day And I think one of the reasons is they wanted to make sure that every single character was seen on screen in that first day Because there's so many characters There's so many storylines going on in the rings of power
[00:10:32] Everybody has their favorite character Everybody has their favorite person in the show So they wanted to make sure that everybody got a moment So this episode opens with Gandalf and Tom Bombadil looking on over the Dark Wizard and his people as Camul returns to Rune So that's a really interesting way of doing it We introduce the Dark Wizard trying to reignite the land of Rune after it has become a desert
[00:10:59] And he's effectively saying once, you know, once that ring of power comes back into my lands here I'll be able to cure the whole lands and they'll be able to come back to the way they were in the past But it doesn't go that way for him when Campbell arrives No, it really doesn't I love this Yeah, no, I kind of love the whole treachery of it You know, you have the Dark Wizard calling him an Oathbreaker But I think there's two things here I think, you know, he tries his wizardry on him
[00:11:28] And clearly that magic, his staff doesn't work And you see the little, well, the big blue gemstone beginning to crack with the Nasnagol holding onto the staff And clearly the magic not working on him I kind of like the quick tack from the Dark Wizard here He goes, I was misunderstood
[00:11:56] You enter here as Sauron's emissary And you have Camul just turning to him and saying Rune belongs to me, old man You see the Dark Wizard in an instance here losing effectively his power base As his acolytes are kind of chanting Hail Sauron and follow Camul out
[00:12:18] But I like this notion of a former king or leader having been kind of usurped himself by the Dark Wizards And coming back and usurping the usurper Absolutely Or reclaiming his rightful place just with an awful lot of dark magic behind him And more Remember, you know, he went there with loads of people from Rune Loads of kings from Rune who had all been usurped by the Dark Wizard
[00:12:47] And now he's coming back to lead an army of 100,000 That he has gained in killing all the rest of them And getting his power ring from Or his ring of power Sorry, I can't call it a power ring That's the lanterns But he's gotten his ring of power He's coming back here He can see that his ring of power is even more powerful than the wizard's magic And the wizard uses that to take over their whole area So, yeah, what an interesting moment But yeah, Ciarán Hines plays this so, so well as the Dark Wizard going
[00:13:15] It really, I don't know, it feels like Trump's government or something When they go, yeah, that's exactly what I meant When I said that we were going to burn down all the churches in the local town You know, or whatever is the new plan of the person that's in charge now Because I had intended to do something completely different But yeah, I think there's a great little moment there Where Ciarán Hines as he changes over But as the Dark Wizard says to him My acolytes aren't owned by you And Camille goes, yeah, okay, I'll see you in a few days' time
[00:13:44] When I have my forces behind me In other words, they will be mine in a few days When there's a hundred thousand people at the door About to take them away from you And they're already chanting, Hail Ciarán Well, exactly And you have Gandalf and Tom here watching on And trying to get out of the chamber Which is kind of an interesting moment here You have Gandalf being left on his own in the end
[00:14:09] And having to just use a bit of distraction to get out But he is followed by someone who is actually killed off By seemingly his magic staff is self-aware Because Gandalf has his back to him I didn't get the feeling that he knew that he was being followed And the guy has drawn his dagger And next thing he's saved from an attack And it's kind of swiped aside
[00:14:38] And this kind of lone assassin But then we have this kind of really interesting piece Where you have this elephant sort of waking up from underneath Kind of covered in sand waking up And you have Gandalf releasing all the armor from its body And seemingly this dark spell that has captured it and enslaved it
[00:15:08] So that's also kind of an interesting thing here That these creatures have also been enslaved here I'm guessing from the dark wizard's magic And what we hear has transpired in Rune Yeah, I think the bigger picture here in Middle-earth Is that a lot of the beasts and animals that are on That are forming part of the army of Sauron
[00:15:35] Are under the spell of Morgoth So we've heard that name a couple of times We hear it later on when we see the fell beast that Sauron rides That effectively they are under a spell To be on the bad side of Middle-earth effectively So that's kind of a little touch to where we get to with Gandalf After this scene He's having a moment where he's freeing the darkness
[00:16:03] From this oliphant It was very cool to see an oliphant in the scene I always thought they were called Mamakil It's a different species of elephant type creature that's there But we've seen the elephants before In the Hobbit and in Lord of the Rings So cool to see one on screen here Yeah, it was, yeah I'm not entirely sure I fully understood that sequence though Of Gandalf having, yes, trying to escape the chamber Without being noticed
[00:16:32] But then being followed And this, maybe it was just to reiterate the point That this land anyway is under, in some ways A dark spell Yeah Purely from the Dark Wizard Absolutely Let alone now we have Camul returning as a Naznagal Who's probably going to make it even darker So like, plus the legacy of Morgoth That, you know, is possibly layers upon layers here Interesting you talk about the oliphant
[00:17:00] And being touched by Morgoth and that And the fell beast Which we hear, you know, used to be an eagle We do have the Naznagal turning kind of a finch into a crow Yep And having that moment as well So, yes, they do And they become the messengers of the Naznagal Yes, they're the kind of long distance messengers So, yeah, I kind of enjoy all that element here But, and I think that is trying to give you that indication of
[00:17:29] You know, the infection that's going across Middle-earth That's spreading out from Sauron And what he's doing in Mordor In service of Morgoth It's like the forest, isn't it? In Lord of the Rings Like Mirkwood and so on Exactly Sort of slowly, an evil resides therein You know, and becoming, I guess, less friendly Sort of nasty nature rather than lovely nature Yes, I suppose it's the influence of Matt
[00:17:59] Yeah, that's kind of the That's part of the themes of Tolkien's Lord of the Rings You know, it's kind of It's not their fault If they hadn't been corrupted by man Then they would have continued on their life As beautiful creatures, beautiful animals In Middle-earth And beautiful trees and ents You know, but with that influence of the darkness of man Comes the evil side Yeah So, not all ravens are evil But the ones that are created from chaffinches
[00:18:28] By Naz and a ghoul are, I guess Yeah But we do get to meet the flame The secret flame When Gandalf is leaving the Dark Wizards lands He encounters the secret flame This is quite a significant moment really Yes, it is really And something a little bit different For people that haven't read The Lord of the Rings And some of the other Tolkien books You probably get You probably can see from this
[00:18:57] That his Christianity and his faith Does play part in his books Which kind of has been ignored In The Lord of the Rings, I think There's no real There's a little bit of an allegorical story Of Christianity playing in the background Here, this seems to be a very specific mention Of a creator here Yes, absolutely The flame that we have here Pretty much describes itself The way The story of creation And I think For sure I mean, I love the look of the set
[00:19:26] The kind of concentric rings The flame above a bowl The sort of monoliths around it Which seemed more just like The rock hewn from The mantle of the earth It didn't look anything Particularly designed In terms of that rock But I love the setting of it But yes This is absolutely a nod To a creator or a god
[00:19:55] That made Middle-earth You have the voice say that You have the five servants Described to save Middle-earth Yes And so, you know In a sense Almost angels You could argue I would say Rather than being disciples Or something like that It feels more in that vein Yeah They're sent to Middle-earth From the other realm I suppose The Astarius, effectively
[00:20:25] So this is really important I think For people who are fans Who've been waiting To find out What happened To all the other wizards It's almost like They're just using this moment To say, right Just to say This did happen There were five Astari sent Here is one of them The dark wizard We learned that he was Called Palando And he had a partner Who was supposed to be Working with him On the side Of the secret flame But he murdered him Because he had
[00:20:54] Greater ambitions Or different ambitions Than what he was being asked to do And once he murdered him The villainy That's inherent In murdering Someone like that Has turned Rune into sand It has turned it Into a desert I think it says The act was so Terrible That The evil Inherent in it Sort of Infected the land And so And so actually You see here The dark wizard Trying to restore The green To the desert
[00:21:24] And sort of With a Kind of A desert lily As he describes it Which fails And dies And he's kind of And we hear That's part of the reason For him wanting The ring of power That he would be able To sort of Bring that back And so Yeah We have all of this Which is really Interesting Yeah Yeah And the biggest reveal Of all There has been an argument Between Gandalf and Tom Of how to deal With the dark wizard This person that's Come in and used Her power from
[00:21:53] All of the Kings of Rune Gandalf wants to Fight against him Tom Bombadil Wants to go on With his life Because that's Kind of Tom Bombadil And it turns out Actually There is a plan For From the great flame That is given Directly to Gandalf It's not to fight Against The dark wizard It is to Save The dark wizard So the two of them Can team up And accomplish Their original Goal Which is To take down The servant Of Morgoth In Mordor Which is Sauron
[00:22:22] So that is the plan It's very Plainly stated We finally have As I said A purpose for Gandalf Your purpose is not to Take down the dark wizard Your purpose is to Save him And the two of you Together can take down Sauron Absolutely And to save Middle-earth It says Arise Servant of The secret flame And I think As well The interesting Thing here Is that It feels like That's what Tom Bombadil Was also Hinting at It is And you know He says Mayhaps You're not Meant to
[00:22:51] Defeat Them I do like As well That all of This Is Shrouded In seemingly Gandalf Being really Over Tom's Singing And riddles As well As Tom Bombadil Is kind of Over the Long conversations From Gandalf He says Long listenings Is hungry Work And It's just I think This kind of They've had
[00:23:21] Enough of One another Is just A really Kind of Nice Moment And You know Tom Starts Singing With that Lovely Like tune That we Heard at The end Of season Two And you Just The look On Gandalf's Face Is he's Really Not Impressed By this He doesn't Really want To start Going through This singing But In the end It's the Rabbit That gets Him off The hook And that Rabbit
[00:23:50] As I say Leads him To the Flame But when He gets Back You have Tom Bombadil Gone Yes In fact You don't Have Tom Bombadil Yes But he does Leave him With the Message to Keep on Singing Effectively So don't Forget To take A moment Of your Time I do Feel That some Of this Was written By People that Don't like Tom Bombadil He's Notoriously Loved by Part of The fandom Hated by Other parts Of the Fandom So I Feel like In the Writer's Room He was
[00:24:20] Represented By both Sides Quite Equally He was Written Really Well The actor That was Playing him Is absolutely Fantastic And then I Feel like The writers Who didn't Like him Got their Hands on Gandalf's Words And moments With him Where it's Like yeah Okay he's Great I get it But sometimes Someone that Is a complete Pacifist And likes To sing A lot Can drive You Absolutely Insane If you Spend Too long With him So let's Move along Alright Thanks Tom For your Time We might Not see You again
[00:24:50] In the Series But he Was Fantastic Yeah Because he Does say It's time For Tom To return To the Withy Windle So I Suspect He's Gone There Yes He's a Traveller Across Middle Earth He may Pop up Again But he Doesn't Necessarily Sit in one Exact Location And in Fact Last season Where he Turned up It was a Bit of a Surprise To Tolkien Fans So Excellent So we May see Him again Keeping them Off guard Exactly Good stuff Before we get Into our Tale number Two We should Also just
[00:25:20] Mention that Gandalf does Get his Signature hat He certainly Does It is Fashion season In Milan And Paris At the moment And here We have A statement Hat It is Very much A part Of Gandalf Indeed It felt like Indiana Jones Though As the hat Just kind of Blows in And he Picks it up And puts it On And looks At the Camera Just to Show you This is Gandalf With hat On It is An iconic Image Of Gandalf I think It is
[00:25:50] The cover Of my Original Lord of The Rings Book That is The cover Of Gandalf With his Big hat So It is Cool to See it Like that But It felt Like Since We went Through About seven Or eight Episodes Of him Trying to Find His staff Last season That his hat Grace The Great Flame Or the Secret Flame Maybe This was Tom Bombadil's Getting Their own Back on Gandalf Saying Yeah We are not Going through That again We are not Having two Seasons Of him Getting His staff
[00:26:20] Right You know Enter Stage Left Gandalf's Hat That was How it Was written So Looks Cool Anyway Let's Get into Tale Number Two It is DDT The Dwarven Thrupple It is Duran Deezer And Thrain Not A Toxic Chemical Or Indeed A WWE Wrestling Move It may Have Been If it Was Actually A Thrupple
[00:26:50] It may Have Been A Wrestling Move But Thrain Thrain Has Been A Really Interesting Character To Come In We Learned Very Quickly As An Audience That The end Of Episode 2 That He's Not On The up And Up He's Working For Sauron Effectively But There's Times
[00:27:36] They're Very Quick To Say No Outright Without Any Kind Of Discussion Whereas Thrain Seems Very Strong He Seems To Know What He Wants He Seems To Work With The People That Are Around Him He Seems To Consider Their Opinions Just Because We Know That He's Working For Sauron He Probably Shouldn't Be King Is Kind Of Secondary To It I Just Love How That's Presented On Screen So We Have The Dwarven Kings Once Again Because Dwarven Kings Want Dwarven Rings
[00:28:07] Presenting Themselves In Front Of Thrain And Disa And Saying Look You're Ruining Us Here You're Going To Cause Our Destruction Because You Have The Ability To Give Us Powers That Could Stand Up Against Sauron We Know That Because They Are Massively Powerful Rings And You've Hidden Them All Away From Us Because Of What You Think And You Haven't Told Us Why You Haven't Given Us Any Opportunity To Have A Discussion About This And Thrain Saying To Them Well Maybe They're Right Maybe That Is
[00:28:36] A Position We Should Be On We Should Maybe We Have To Think About This A bit Yeah I Mean It's All Coming From The Fact That They Saw Duran The Third And His Descent Into Greed Effectively He Became Tainted With Greed Duran And Deezer Saw Yes Yeah Exactly It's The Same Argument From Boromir In Fellowship Of The Ring Around Using The Weapon Of Their Enemy Against Them This Is What They're Effectively Saying So There's A lot Of Inherent
[00:29:06] Sympathy I Would Say With Deezer And During The Fourth Position Here They Have Witnessed It They've Experienced It I Guess They've Also Got Strong Allies With The Elves With Elrond So Again Other Aspects Here Feeding Into It But They're Just Not Very Good At Communicating It But What Really Comes Out Here Is Thorain Showing His True Colors Or Springing That Trap That We
[00:29:35] Learned About Because He Suddenly Supports The Blue Lords In This Request Of Them And You See Them Both Turning To Him Certainly Duran Giving Him The Side Eye But Also It's More Than That Because He Then Asks If The Ring Was So Corrupted So Different Than What He Remembers His Own Father To Be Then He Asks Whether That Ring Was On His Finger Before Or
[00:30:05] After He Named Duran As His Successor So He Makes The Play For The Sympathy Of The Lords That Are There As Well As The Play For The Throne And Navi In fairness To Him Being Honest As Anything Confirms That He Did Have The Ring On His Finger And So All Of A SUDDEN This Now Puts The Succession Into Dispute And So There's This Trial By Combat
[00:30:35] By Ole's Will And So Like I Kind of Like This Brutus Moment Here From Thrain Because I Think Duran Immediately Senses It Disa Certainly Does Because Of Her Past Relationship With Thrain But Also I Think Because What We Have Is Disa Is Concerned That Thrain Will Actually Be Successful In This
[00:31:04] Attempt Through Trial By Combat Because He Will Rile Up Duran And He'll Lose Because He's Too Much Of A Hot Head As She Says And In Fairness She Foreshadows Exactly What Happens And She Knows Her Loved One Better Than He Does But It Is Suddenly As Well Complicated By Thrain And Disa's Previous Little Fling And That Is The Complicating
[00:31:34] Factor Here And Also The Fact That Duran's Son Gamli Saw Disa And Thrain Talking About This Alone In Their Home So You know This Is All Complicating Factors That Come In It's Interesting As Well With Navi Because I Was Like Just Going You Could Have Just Lied Here But At Least We Do Get His
[00:32:04] Explanation Which Is You Know My Role Here Is To Govern This Mountain I Don't Have An Allegiance To My
[00:33:01] deserve the throne after what's happened here. Agreed. I do like that he changes tact, though, because he does try to get Deezer to convince Duran to give up the seven rings, and then he'll withdraw his claim. But she's not really having any of that, so he also does threaten her with exposing their previous dalliance, effectively, which leads to Deezer telling Duran the truth about her mistake.
[00:33:31] Now, interestingly, Duran does say, I have regrets of my own during that time, and I'm just wondering what that meant. Does it mean that he also had a little fling? It does, yeah. He says, was it the argument about, and they both kind of say at the same time, the serving girl in the bar, something like that. They broke up because Duran cheated, is what it sounds like, and while they were on a break, she slept with his brother. It has a lot of, a lot of,
[00:34:01] we were on a break from friends moments there between the conversation between the two of them. It's long past the things done. Duran's issue is that Deezer didn't tell him that he had the relationship. It takes him a while to get over it because he's only just being told about it now. What's it, 20 years after it happened, effectively? She's suddenly telling him about it now, so that's more of Duran's problem, and then when he finds out from his son, well, as late as this morning,
[00:34:32] she was touching his face in the room when they were talking about their relationship, and I walked in on them. That's what throws Duran over the edge. Like, he says, we are stronger as a couple, but he's only literally just learned about it, and Deezer has tried to provide him with the way to build a bridge and get over it while telling him she cheated on him with his brother, and then when a son comes out and says, I saw them together this morning, and makes the motion of one rubbing the other's face or rubbing the other's beard,
[00:35:01] Duran loses it during the fight. I love how this plays out because Deezer is not close to Duran at that moment, like physically, and you see the panic on this kind of conversation that she kind of knows what's about. She knows what it's about, but she can't really hear it. You just have the hot-headedness returning to Duran,
[00:35:29] and he goes after Thrain completely in a non-strategic, non-tactical way. Thrain ultimately kind of... Salt in your eye. Yeah, salt in the eye. Back of an axe to your head. Back of an axe to your head. I love the phrase that is used for that, which is knock him dark. Yes. It's just a really nice little phrase.
[00:35:56] You know if they come up with a phrase like that, it happens every week in the pub. You know, that's a race of people that beat the crap out of each other often enough to have a term for knock him dark. It means they do it a lot. Yes. But I like the fact that, you know, this trial by combat, they do say a bit earlier, all we need to do is knock him dark. So it's not as such to the death like most of those trial by combat things are.
[00:36:26] It's an option. And it is interesting. In the moment of choice, Thrain turns the axe around to knock him dark. Yes. He does have that moment of sympathy, clarity or compassion, whatever you want to call it. And again, this notion of the actions of people and how they may impact Middle Earth has always run through it. And it's all really interesting. Absolutely. And so I kind of just liked that moment here. Yeah.
[00:36:56] Yeah, definitely. And there it is. Thrain, the new leader and has now claimed the throne of Khazad-dum. Yeah. We've kind of seen the minds of Moria and Khazad-dum a couple of thousand years in the future. Can't blame Thrain for all of that, but let's see how it plays out across the rest of the season. Let's get over to the other side of Middle Earth for tale number three. Just for a quick one, I think, visit to Numenor and dealing with Kemen's plan.
[00:37:25] He's been sent to the shores of where the faithful are up in the west. And he's there to capture Elendil, the leader of the faithful. Yeah, I mean, I think initially it's just good to see the havens of the faithful here. You have Elendil's son sort of training the troops, putting them through their drills and giving them the advice that, yes, you were knocked on the floor,
[00:37:55] yet this is just training. If it's the guards of Farazan, then you'll be dead. But ultimately what you see here is Elendil coming to his son and saying, you're the only person I trust, but we've been told there is a spy in the havens and we need to root them out. And so they are aware that there is a meeting happening where there'll be an exchange
[00:38:22] and they look to try and sort of surprise this traitor effectively in the act of working with the enemy. Exactly. And turns out to be a ruse to get Elendil, which they do. But as I kind of mentioned up front earlier on, it really is just to have these two characters to have a chat, isn't it? And Elendil need to have a conversation about Kemmen's opinions
[00:38:52] and why Kemmen is the way he is. It's weird. It was only at this moment that I realized there was a little outstanding unresolved question that was mentioned back in season two of Rings of Power where Kemmen said, where Farazan sent Kemmen to Middle Earth to do his bidding over there and kind of said, oh, I have a secret about your mother that I'll tell you when you get back and do all my work and he went over, did it, came back and now we find out what the secret is. The secret was
[00:39:21] that his mother was a lady of the night, sold her wares to anyone that would pay it at night and Kemmen was the product of one of those unions and when she told Farazan that Kemmen was the product of someone that had paid for sex with her, that he strangled or killed or smothered Kemmen's mother and allowed Kemmen to live and allowed him to become the future heir heir of Farazan. Well, actually, he's still holding that over him at the moment. He's saying if he accomplishes
[00:39:50] his job up here in the West, he will be named heir of Farazan. And Kemmen says, and because he did that, I've spent my entire life trying to make sure that I do everything I possibly can to keep Al Farazan happy and to make sure that I'm the best little boy I can ever possibly imagine being. And you see the look of revulsion on Alendil's face when he's hearing this story from Kemmen going, that's what you got when your father smothered your mother? That's what you got out of it
[00:40:20] is to make sure that you keep him happy and that you make sure he thinks you're the best little boy that could ever possibly be? Has anyone ever had that kind of relationship with their father apart from, like, you know, Lance Stroll in the form of the one? That's the only current comparison I can think of. But, my God, Kemmen's life, he's an awful, awful character and now you see the kind of lessons he learns from the people around him. Yeah, not a great guy. Yeah, no, it's not really.
[00:40:49] So, yeah, it's interesting but I like how the tables get turned here. You know, Alendil goes from being the captive to being the captor as the prison cart or carriage that is taking him to the capital of Numenor is stopped seemingly by Numenorean guards from the city but actually it is an Aryan who has sort of changed
[00:41:19] his troops into the dead guards that he killed whilst trying to save Alendil from being captured. And I like just how he rescues his dad. I like his dad's wise words because Temmin is captured but an Aryan is going to kill him and he says like, no, because he's worth more to us alive. It's always a useful reminder, you know, stop being
[00:41:49] quite so hot-headed like Durin and maybe it could work out better. Equally, we don't know at what cost it might be for keeping Kemmen alive. Certainly, you know, certainly he does not react to being beaten well. No, he does not. And he does like to take revenge. So, you know, that's kind of interesting here. Kemmen here also in the back of the
[00:42:19] carriage does inform Alendil of the death of his daughter, Iarian. Not in the nicest ways either. No. And in a sense, that's why you do kind of wish he'd maybe just been pinned with another crossbow bolt and just to make it really sting or, you know, he's suddenly given sort of fish and chips with lots of vinegar on it. So that his bloody hand would be really hurt. I must say, I did love the move though.
[00:42:48] I loved seeing Alendil's crossbow bolt go into his hand and then he follows it up with a punch to the face. It's like, God, if anybody deserves a punch to the face more again in this series, I don't know them. Even Sauron sometimes doesn't deserve as much of a punch to the face as Kemen. But you'd suspect that eventually Kemen's going to get one of the rings of power as a king of Numenor. Right, Neville. Who's Neville? Neville Chamberlain, the appeaser.
[00:43:18] Peace in our time. I've just come from Sauron. He said he's not going to rule Middle Earth. No, that's not what I'm thinking. I'm just thinking Kemen deserves a bit of a slap occasionally. Oh, that's true. The only other thing about Numenor in this episode really is that we get a little moment with King Gil-galad, the Elven King, and Elrond coming over to him to plead with them to speak to the Numenoreans, try and get them on their side. Gil-galad and Cirdan reveal that they actually
[00:43:47] did reach out to Numenor and they got the message back from Farazan saying, no, we've got to deal with our stuff over here. You know, but I love that Elrond kind of goes, yeah, I think some kings, especially kings of men, want to have the king come visit them and talk to them about it rather than just get a letter. So let's get in the boats and head on over to Numenor. Yeah, I mean, I have to say I did quite like how that was put because it comes out that distrust for mortal men,
[00:44:18] but equally, he says, but must deal with him king to king and not really just sending a letter. And you have Kherdan saying, yes, you must go and humble yourself in front of him to give the elves hope because we do have this moment slightly earlier on where they're kind of looking across a field of battle and Kherdan is trying to say, yes, it looks awful, yes, it looks hopeless, but it gives us
[00:44:48] one more day of freedom that is hope enough. Here he's trying to say, look, Gil-Glad, get on your horse, meet with the Numenoreans. He might be a big prima donna, but you're going to have to just suck it up so that we get this alliance because we are losing allies. We got that from the previous episodes. Exactly. The allies are getting quite thin on the ground as each one of them gets turned into a Naznagel. So,
[00:45:18] yes, there's not many worlds of men left in which they can ask for aid and assistance. It did really feel like Gil-Glad was going, but I asked him for aid and he said no. Who dares says no to the king of the elves if he says no? My pride tells me I cannot possibly ask him again. You really need to learn something about these people. But definitely that moment with Kherdan made me think that himself and Tom Bombadil
[00:45:48] will go off and live together in their positivity somewhere else in Middle Earth. Everything is turned into a positive. Every time somebody gives them a negative we'll flip it on its head. Yes, agreed. So, I just wanted to mention that they will be on their trip. So, the next time we see them, we may be seeing them over in Numenor. Yeah, exactly. That'd where Kherdan says to him, we need somebody that
[00:46:18] knows Numenor. We learned again, or we mentioned again, that Elrond's brother lived as a human, had chosen to live life as a human amongst the Numenoreans. So, that's where Elrond's brother lived his life. Yes, exactly. Excellent. Let's get into tale number four, the fortress of Gundabad. Yes, absolutely. This is the trip of the fellowship to Gundabad. We have
[00:46:48] Marnuk and Galadriel and Arandir travelling all the way up to Gundabad. I really like this because, again, it evokes those great fellowship journeys across Middle-Earth to get to the destination. There's definitely moments of that journey for Frodo, Sam and Gollum with Marnuk playing the part of Gollum in there. Yes, absolutely. I think that's why I really enjoyed this. I think as well what I really enjoyed is
[00:47:18] it is the is he isn't he of Marnuk. Is he on their side? Is he not? I like how it keeps evolving here. Just because he looks so orcish and oricky so he looks immediately distrustful. But we have hints along the way where even it's that he says they should go a different way
[00:47:47] because there's troop movements and will get caught in the trebuchet fire. And you have around distrusting Marnuk even more. How would you know of these strategic troop movements? It's all these kind of things. And then he sees that Coldfell is being attacked by the trebuchet fire and rejoins them because Galadriel basically
[00:48:17] allows him to leave this mini fellowship because he doesn't trust Marnuk enough in order to then put his life on the line by being his prisoner and wearing effectively shackles which is the whole way Marnuk was looking to bring them into Gundabad. You're my prisoners. Then you realize that he's a general and he says I think I've played my
[00:48:47] part well as he's in Gundabad and has handed over them to the orcs at the fortress and then he comes good and I loved all that all the way through and I just think it plays so well so it really felt like at any moment the words that Marnuk were saying could be true he's saying things like if we just hold out long enough
[00:49:17] I've played it well enough that Saron is on his way and if we just hold out we all of us will get the he's handing over the ring of Galadriel to Saron which is what he needs to complete his plan and potentially this remaining elven smith he does think
[00:49:47] is there he won't even need the smith that's the whole point was the smith myth is what was going through my head maybe it's not there and when we find out that the smith is dead even more so I was going has the same knowledge as the smith has and again you're going oh has he played everybody from the start did you know that she was dead because her under
[00:50:17] says she's been dead for months and Marnuk sniffs the air and says no actually only just a few weeks and you're going but is he just playing or is it just a little sly nod to the fact that elves live so long that they have no idea how to judge time and those minor minutes and seconds and weeks and months when they judge things in centuries speaking of centuries we also find Celeborn Galadriel's husband in the prison cell opposite
[00:50:46] the dead smith this I have but they got me again and brought me back because it's in a high mountain you know but he knows all the routines like down to a T it did feel like the great escape in that sense where they're like yes this is how
[00:51:16] the guard movements are these are the guards on patrol these are their rank this one has the key for the next floor and like it was just really good how he kind of went through that because he does ultimately persuade them to release him from the cell to help them get out of Gundabad because we have
[00:51:55] elaborating and he goes no I don't know any of these people because he's literally a thousand years old if not more he's listing all leaders of the elven kind from millennia ago and Arandir has no idea who he is I love how this plays out again you're right it does feel like the great escape that moment when he leaves them you're
[00:52:25] saying that as if something bad happens out there no no it's absolutely fine that's where all this sunlight and flowers are yeah grand and then he hears it's Galadriel and instantly brings them down and what a way to reintroduce Galadriel and Selaborne because of course she's not going to go down without a massive fight she's down there taking out all of the guards that are around her she takes them all out and drops their sword to the ground as she sees her husband and
[00:52:55] a reminder in the making of documentary that she hasn't seen Galadriel for about a millennia at this date about a thousand years and bad enough after John goes away for a week let alone go away for a thousand years John what's your name again speak up say that but yes their love lasts forever being a thousand years old way older than that they're like ten thousand
[00:53:25] years exactly exactly I mean yeah it's just really good how they're reunited I love how as well this is all playing out with the knowledge that you have Sauron in the background trying to understand more about this Orc Manuk as much as possible and that you know there's these few little snippets were he realizes that he was at Eregion in the battle
[00:53:54] and that he's taking this party from Rivendell northwards that's where Gundabad is is and you have he brings these two other elves that he manipulates to tell him did they remember this Orc and you hear that yes but they were passed off to another whilst he headed north to take the
[00:54:24] elven smith up to Gundabad so this deduction is happening by Sauron at the same time I do like the fact that the handler saying we can saddle some horses that will take weeks and he's like no saddle the beast meaning the fell beasts that used to be the giant eagles so I really like this because the handler basically
[00:54:54] gets eaten because his issue has been he's been giving dead meat when he needs to give live flesh that the beast the fell beast can effectively hunt so I love how he gets chucked off the balcony by the nasnagel and gets slurped up by the fell beast this literally this was shagat who seems to be well you would think has been Sauron's right hand orc
[00:55:23] from the whole season so far he's been the person that's been relaying information to Sauron all the time and he just gets literally dispatched within one second because the fell beast need flesh not the carrion that you've been giving to them and he just throws them off the side and I love that we see that silhouette in the background as the fell beast flies in the air you see him throwing the body in the air and swallowing it
[00:55:53] I think that reminded me of Jurassic park with the orc being eaten by him yes yeah and I do also quickly the explosion of the two elves because he's given tainted water with this fire drake poison taken from the glands around his neck so yes I mean ultimately
[00:56:22] it forces the husband I think Karamir was his name to help Sauron in exchange for the antidote which then he can't get the top off it so I think she burps or breathes out and is consumed by fire along with him so yes it's really harsh it's the way Sauron says I put just a drop in the water she better not
[00:56:52] cough and then the husband pleads for her life and he goes it's already done but you have the opportunity to have it undone if you give me the information I want and you want the antidote but it's already done basically he's saying I've already killed both of you but you fire drake it's his
[00:57:21] poison from his glands and you're like okay you're just psychotic here so it's very brutal but yeah there's one more movement in Gundabad that we need to talk about let's get on to our tale number five which is the other big reveal of the episode the Naznagul we could have guessed that this was going to happen obviously again
[00:57:51] all four episodes released in one day and this was part of the reason because you were going to go away for a week after watching the first couple of episodes that Theo
[00:58:21] of course had met Sauron when he was Halbrand back in the first season of Rings of Paris and they actually had got a connection in the past so did Sauron recognise him the second he saw him in the tower and realised hang on a markings maybe it's that but that also seemed to be the markings could
[00:58:51] only come from ancient dark sword hilt so I think it was that but you never know the fact that he's playing with his mind he's getting in at Theo about his mother and what she did all of that stuff you is that Theo as a Naznagul is teased a little bit you see
[00:59:20] Sauron in episode three sort of crowning this new Naznagul but you don't see that it's Theo and you don't see Theo around and we have been left with him possibly making that decision that choice so we're not clear he doesn't speak as soon as he speaks on the top of Gundabad you know it's Theo and I think yes to me
[00:59:50] this is a really great through line of Theo's story because he's always teased with the dark side here it's always kind of intrigued him and thralled him he's felt it as being part of that through Arondir but Arondir then left
[01:00:20] he was in Palagir with Kemen the worst person you would want looking over this outpost and you know so his mind has drifted back to that dark side and it's that sort of to-ing and fro-ing of the darkness and the light in Theo and for me this really kind of feels right
[01:00:50] makes sense again maybe he's also an inside man who knows because the only thing I would say as to why he might be I don't personally think that that's the case but I do like the fact like Sauron basically gave the order as he comes into Gundabad and that he wants the orc and he wants Galadriel
[01:01:20] and Theo kills Manuk the orc so I'm like why you know and he stalls long enough now he does but ultimately he kills Rondir at the order it feels like it's with the order of Sauron with him still wearing the ring he couldn't resist it because it feels like a really quick motion of him you know so
[01:01:50] that I really thought was fascinating in this like he wasn't fully in control yeah it's the right hand which is the hand that's carried the ring that's what he picks the sword up and stabs our under straight through after saying two seconds beforehand get out of he wants Galadriel get out of here you're free to go he's letting him walk away I think the reason he kills Marnuk is more clear from
[01:02:19] what happened just beforehand again we were questioning whether Marnuk was still on the side of Sauron was still playing both sides he he he stood in front of what we know now was Theo and said to him oh this is all a Jape I was only playing and then he released the prisoners so it's when he
[01:02:58] to think Theo has chosen to kill him because he is not on the side of Sauron but yes the conversation between Arandir and Theo is really important he's saying to him I left you behind but we will leave together here he's regretting leaving him behind because look what's happened look at the innocence that's been taken away he's now not only has he had a horrible five years working for horrible Kemen he's now
[01:03:27] become a Naznagul under the control of Sauron and as you say it's that moment where they're reaching out Theo is effectively looks like about to accept Arandir's request for him to leave he's at least reaching out to shake his hand and then Arandir's telling him to take off the ring but Sauron walks past to the background and says kill him and instantly Theo stabs him so it is almost like he has no way as you say of stopping the control
[01:03:57] of Sauron over the ring and over him yeah I mean it's also you know it's tragic for Theo in this moment but it also as well it just again it plays out what Arandir foreshadows shadowed previously around other men with that small battle that we see in the woodland where he says in response to
[01:04:27] Galadriel who said well you didn't put the swords in their hands he said well I did when I failed them I failed men by leaving and you know he's got Theo on his mind when he says that and here absolutely that loss of that positive role model is apparent being able to keep him on the straight and narrow which ultimately is what has been
[01:04:56] lost from the death of his mum Bronwyn the awful conditions under the Numenoreans what's he got left other than the faint hope that he previously had that maybe somehow this would change his fortunes and that's what Sauron has also played on in order to bring him to his side so yeah this I mean this is a huge moment Aranda's been
[01:05:26] certainly a favourite of mine he's been ever present in these seasons of Rings of Power absolutely loved him the fact that it is also Theo I think you know is tragic and also just a fantastic play out of the story that's happened and it feels right for Theo for me to be a Nas Nagal here to be honest yeah and it's interesting the actor
[01:05:55] himself said in an interview in the behind the scenes he says here I am standing with my old father figure side by side with my new father figure and I'm killing the old to go with the new he's like that just makes total sense maybe I've made the wrong choice Charlie Vickers beside him goes no I think you made the harsh he really does embody the role of it but yeah it's really sad to see Arandir I love that you know one of his final lines is I will not run from the shadow he's not willing to leave Theo behind
[01:06:25] now that he's seen what he's become but he's gone way too far Arandir drops his sword at that moment he doesn't pick up his sword again he's not going to fight Theo if Theo chooses to do what he's going to do Arandir will not stop him has to be for Landraval the Prince of the Eagles because that is such a cool catch that he does when you know to escape
[01:06:55] Sauron Celeborn and Galadriel jump off the roof of Gundabad it's just a very cool moment but I think the eagle here Landraval is ultimately one of the coolest things I've seen because just that moment where Galadriel sends up the firework I love how it's camouflaged against the rock of the mountain with the snow on its feathers and it kind of shakes them off
[01:07:25] and then it's kind of as it comes in there's all the orcs firing the arrows so it dives down and clasps with its claws onto the side of the fortress and waits going well you know throw yourself off here I can't fly up I'll catch you don't worry I can't fly up maybe that's the reason why he's called the prince of the eagles not like the son of the king maybe he's just as cool as prince he can also tell us
[01:07:54] what it sounds like when does cry but doing that cool move where he grabs him out of the air flips over and then flies off is just awesome absolutely love him the best dancer of the eagles and best singer of the eagles probably as well excellent the prince of eagles right I think that's it for all of our major moments and major points I've just got one other thing to mention because I didn't find a space to pop it in throughout there but on the journey up to Gundabad
[01:08:25] we have another little Lord of the Rings moment I think with Galadriel and Marnuk and Arondir where they hide from the ring rates in the brush it really does remind you of the hobbits hiding from the ring it's really classic callback and then Galadriel using her power where she gets the moth that Marnuk had put into his pouch and then turns it into a butterfly sends the butterfly off to distract them and then the butterfly turns into thousands
[01:08:54] of butterflies in the air it's so cool the way it's just surrounding them again using that power of nature you know it's a cool way to see it oh absolutely and I think on the reverse side of that I mentioned it before I just really enjoyed the Nasnegall as they're kind of tracking from this group from Rivendell how he turns the finch into a crow and I love then how it shows
[01:09:24] the crows circling around Baradour and just having Sauron taking in all the intel from the crows and I like the moment where you hear the crows cawing and cawing and then you just hear go north it's really such a great little moment hearing that and seeing that
[01:09:54] corruption of the finch into the crow or the raven and yeah very cool little moment there and one other thing just from Arandir is you know not just his treatment of Theo and what he says there but it is also how he also goes back to save Manuk on the top there and a bit earlier I think it was in
[01:10:23] episode three where Arandir is proven wrong by Manuk he has protected them from travelling near to an orc army and he says you know he goes an Uruk's word is worth more than I allowed so I kind of like that moment of reflection from Arandir as well absolutely great moments in these episodes overall John what did
[01:10:53] you think of the two episodes of the rings of power for me the secret fire I would give four and a I thought that was a nice little touch so we've got
[01:11:23] both sides represent and Gundabad I'd give it five stiff smiths out of five stiff as a board she was poor love never able to forge a ring again not the only elf in the episode unfortunately no exactly well she the old smithy
[01:11:53] so yeah absolutely loved these two episodes again a real strong opening with these first four episodes for me in one fell day we are down to half the season I know what are you doing I know I know but I episodes but before we do we do have some feedback
[01:12:22] from Dr. Bob Phillips on episode one over on our discord channel and Dr. Bob says I have forgotten quite how many storylines you have to keep your head around while you're watching this but they did a valiant job of including the wild kick in order to be stabbed
[01:12:52] me and the use of a minion as both shield and lance in collateral's joust deep in the minds it's good to know that teenagers are teenagers whether they be teenage or not or royalty and that brothers that live a long way away can still remember when parents got cross best line of and we probably
[01:13:22] shouldn't talk about exactly how kinky the throne nazgul elect battling scene was well yes throw the sword down and you all battle for your place at my right hand amongst yourselves you know yeah he's sitting on a throne of helmets from dead elves as well so yeah he's effectively just created his throne
[01:14:17] sword really struggling with the story it looks far better than previously and great to see a bit of peace introduced but the lore and the other stories outside of lord of the rings unfortunately I'm that person I read the hobbit when I was 10 42 years ago and fell in love with the stories and writing I'm really finding frustration with the changes they might seem really minor but some are just ludicrous the Palantiri slash teams meeting for one thank god Microsoft wasn't down then I'll
[01:14:47] stick with it but I think I'll be dipping in and out for short bursts and for as long as my annoyance can stand it still be listening to podcast each week though just to hear you and others thoughts thanks so much Richard so glad we can be part of your podcast week even if it is something maybe you're not entirely with at the moment I think from our side or
[01:15:23] when I was reading the books around 10 or 12 it was just like no and that's where I probably didn't quite gel with Tom Bumble till if I'm totally honest you got to chapter 12 when they're on the journey and went oh this is not
[01:15:53] you yourself probably went I'm sure I'll just read the sequel to The Hobbit and then found this massive tome of 5,000 pages long to try and get through and yeah it's probably the wrong time to read to read the Lord of the Rings but when you come back to it later in life it's definitely well worth the read I love it I must I'm really hoping that I can get to read it again soon but yes the moment again using the visual of Elendil talking to Isildur
[01:16:24] using their video call I think somebody else called it like a holodeck from Star Trek which I can kind of see as well you possibly yes it kind of passed me by that being potentially heretical but it's terrible you wouldn't like you would never see something like that no
[01:16:54] the use of Palantir to create a tunnel to charge away in someone's mindscape the more you say the more it does sound pretty grim we just saw for like eight episodes of vision quest but there's an explanation for it there you just wouldn't do it Palantir but I'm totally with you around the fact that there is a really good bit of pace here for example Gandalf's hat as we discussed that really set the pace and also yes I think it's
[01:17:24] always looked really good actually but I think it's looking as good if not better as you say Richard I TV budget shouldn't be on television like the destruction of Mordor everybody points to that episode in season one now you get to the opening of season three and you go wow this is stunning from first second absolutely I must say I really enjoyed
[01:17:53] sort of the long shot the wide shot of Gundabad and then going into it where it almost looked like it was destroyed and wrecked and then in amongst the kind of higgledy piggledy sort of unkemptness of it there is this working fortress I thought that was a really good sort of look to it and I loved how you know from afar it's kind of almost forms over the full
[01:18:23] height of a mountain so yeah very very cool look there so great stuff thanks Richard for your feedback on episode two also on episode two dr. bob says this is definitely one of those times when my suspension of disbelief was too strong the caterpillar eating uruk was just too realistic also too real were the interminable strategy meetings the exceptional difficulty in getting your colleagues obscure video
[01:18:52] conferencing system to log in they can never get out shock to see the faces of the naz ghoulish lords I'd forgotten they were truly awful humans before they became wraiths lovely stuff dr. bob yeah absolutely I mean I think that whole moment of
[01:19:22] Sauron coercing Theo here is I mean it's really well played within the show and you feel that manipulation you know just to the core of you from Sauron you see those real world parallels of county lines gangs and people using children to do drug running and that kind of stuff you really see that parallel in the way
[01:19:52] that Sauron is manipulating Theo as well so yeah really it's a really well told story in here in this fantasy world but yeah tough stories this season absolutely shying away from the darkness at all yeah thanks so much dr. bob thanks dr. bob on episode three we got an email in from coffee and vodka who says greetings fellow butter fly me to the moon defenders so tom bombadil is the dark wizard former partner now a spirit moved
[01:20:22] on marnuk on the level i'll just be along for the journey from here on out trying to figure out the zigs and zags and getting it generally wrong has made me all confused and sleepy elendale has been captured but not before finding out he's lost his daughter soon afterwards an arian is left in the paddy wagon dust as it carries his father off not a fortunate family we get more of a galactic origin story a journey reminiscent of Frodo salmon golems pretty much everything but what I'd missed most nurian the
[01:20:51] harfoots still another stellar one bit of a break before the next though these things are filling 4.5 shoulder blades rabbit fire expositions and parched petulant pachyderms out of five peace and take care coffee and vodka I think I got through the four p's there excellent yes picked a pickled pepper something yeah lovely stuff coffee and vodka yeah that's an interesting one
[01:21:20] about Tom Bombadil I hadn't really maybe thought of it along those lines and I have to say I'm not saying I know whether that's the case or not but it's kind of an interesting thought about whether Tom is the Dark Wizard's former partner I don't think so no I never really heard that around Tom Bombadil but I kind of like the notion of it at least within the storytelling that's been done with the Rings of Power
[01:21:50] like it's kind of quite a nice notion and there's things that they can't talk about we've mentioned before they don't have the rights to Samarillion so they can't mention some of the characters so to get some of the Dark Wizard's backstory they may have had to pay a good couple of million extra to get some of the names from that but yeah they just need to parse out the Dark Wizard it's really funny in the synopsis earlier on I had that horrible thing of when we were doing the synopsis for season one and two
[01:22:20] where we have to mention the stranger over and over again knowing he's going to be Gandalf at some point in the future can we when Gandalf saves him from being the Dark Wizard in the future but hopefully we'll be able to call him something in the future absolutely but you're right they're very
[01:22:50] very dense episodes and for the next one but we have got your feedback in episode four absolutely thanks so much coffee and vodka also on
[01:23:20] facebook about episode four we have Lisa Buckland who says oh poor Theo so tragic keep wondering if this is it for him and he will descend totally into killing he hasn't been truly evil yet can Galadriel and Nenya save him also how horrible Sauron and his ring made him kill Arondir I still haven't recovered after a second watch RIP to the most elvish of them
[01:23:50] all thanks so much Lisa yeah absolutely I so be interesting to see how this plays out further for sure will we see Theo become
[01:24:20] truly evil is it too late for him or how will the memory of Arondir last here yeah yeah yeah yeah like that's the interesting part of it isn't you know we know that for example the three elven rings they do change hands in the future we know that because we've seen those three elven rings on different elven hands in the future yeah so is that also possible of the Naznagul we see Theo becoming a Naznagul here but if he rejects it
[01:24:49] and leaves and gets replaced by another Naznagul that's a possibility for the drama of the show that maybe he rejects Sarah you know that's that's entirely possible there is there is still good in him as they once said about Darth Vader so maybe that could be the story of Theo maybe he's not going to descend deeper and become the lead Naznagul maybe he will turn on them now having murdered Arandir maybe that's a reason for him to turn on Sauron yes exactly good stuff
[01:25:19] thanks Lisa also on episode 4 an underpad escapade was filled with surprises and twists former husbands potential double crosses altered eagles and ensorcelled stepson and the deaths of Arandir and
[01:25:49] Marnuk Kazakh Doom had its own share of other shoe droppings ultimately tipping on the comments of one worthless whelp or devoted son depending on your perspective all this and an elven plan to entreat Numenor towards an alliance a fine capper on the first half of an excellent season five live bait biting beasties bad brother betrayals and strange
[01:26:18] bedfellows out of five peace and take care coffee and vodka fantastic yeah it really was a great way to close out the season really sad way to close it on prime video and they do a bit of a flashback to all of his big moments over the course of the last three seasons you realize how central the Rondear is I did get a bit of a tear in my eye again watching that central character for these three seasons
[01:26:48] really sad to see him go yeah absolutely I'm hoping we kind of get sort of the memories of him being carried through by the other elves and maybe you know sort of that sort of angelic white glow that you get sometimes off the
[01:27:19] four episodes of this for sure absolutely well that's it for our feedback for this episode if you want to send us in more feedback you can email us to feedback at tvpodcastindustries.com pop on over to our Facebook group at facebook.com slash groups slash tvpodcastindustries or as we mentioned pop on over to our discord and join us in there the spoiler post up for each of the episodes of Rings of Power if you go and see Rings of Power episode 7 in the cinema next week send in your thoughts tell us what you think of it in the cinema I'd love to see one of these episodes on the big screen
[01:27:48] and apparently it's a very big one and that's part of the reason they're putting it on the big screen so that'll be interesting excellent stuff yeah looking forward to seeing if we can make it for episode 7 it's across the road and it's on a Monday night John what else are we doing exactly thanks so much for joining us we'll be back next time with another two episodes yes absolutely those two episodes are episode 5 the Lady of Lorien and episode 6 from Valinor
[01:28:18] can't wait for that and until next time fellow ringers thank you so much for joining us until then keep watching keep listening and of course don't stray from the past bye a little nod to the heart floods there John exactly bye bye bye bye bye bye Thank you.

