After two years John and Derek are back in Middle Earth to discuss The Lord of The Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 Episodes 1 and 2. As both episodes were released on Prime Video together we will be spoiling everything about these in this discussion.
Our Rings of Power Season 3 podcast is Dedicated to the memory of our beloved Dorothy Harrison who passed away this year.
The Rings Of Power Season 3 Episode 1 and 2 Details
Season 3 Episode 1 "Marnûkh"
Episode Written by J. D. Payne and Patrick McKay
Episode Directed by Charlotte Brändström
Season 3 Episode 2 “The Gift of Men”
Episode directed by Charlotte Brändström
Episode written by Justin Doble
Based on "The Lord of the Rings" and appendices by J.R.R. Tolkien
Episode 1 "Marnûkh" Synopsis
Five years after the fall of Eregion and the death of Celebrimbor, Sauron's orc armies cover most of Western Middle-Earth. Their progress has been halted on both sides Lindon and Rivendell, where the uncorrupted Elven Rings of Power block his progress.
Obsessed with gaining control of the rings, the dark one toils in his forge at Barad-dûr to create one ring to rule them all. Unsuccessful, he also persuades mortal men, including Khamül of Rhün, to become his ring-sevants or Nazgnagûl where they are gifted a ring of power in exchange for their complete devotion to Sauron.
Meanwhile in the Kazad-Dum and the mines of Moria, King Durin IV secretly armours the Elven army through his alliance with Elrond, but the dwarves will not claim a side in the war. A rogue orc named Marnûkh arrives at the mines declaring he has a message for the elf, Galadriel, that could change their fortunes in the war against the dark lord.
Elsewhere in Pelargir, Theo and his people are enslaved cutting down forests and decimating their lands to support Kemen and the Nūmenoreons. But when Kemen discards an invite from Sauron for a Ring of Power, Theo picks it up instead.
Episode 2 “The Gift of Men” Synopsis
Across the Sundering Seas in Nūmenor, High King Ar-Pharazōn is attacked by an assassin from the Faithful, shown to be Isildur. In their investigation into the attack they vow to destroy the Faithful in their havens on the Western Shores. Isildur, helped by his sister, Ëarien, uses a Palantir to warn his father Elendil. Meanwhile, at the same time, Pharazōn's suspicions uncovers the faithful spy of all these years, Ëarien. To avoid helping the illegitimate regent, Ëarien walks off a balcony to her death.
Back in the Mines of Moria, King Durin IV's brother Thrain arrives. After concerns that he would usurp the throne, Thrain bends the knee and defends Durin against any challenge. This includes two Nazgnagûl who try to force Durin to join the forces of Mordor. Later, Thrain secretly meets with the Nazgnagûl, admonishing them for coming to him in Kazad-Dum when he has already set the trap for his brother as he agreed with Sauron.
In Rivendell the orc informant Marnūkh convinces Galadriel and Arondir to travel to the orc prison of Gundabad to rescue the last remaining Elven smith from Eregion who holds the knowledge of Celebrimbor, and to prevent Sauron gaining the remaining secrets that will help him create the one ring.
Meanwhile in Barad-dur, Sauron perverts Theo. After forcing him to battle to the death with his kinsmen, he informs Theo that his father was once a protector and nobleman of Mordor, which is why Theo held such a strong connection to Sauron's weaponry. He shares that his father was murdered by his mother Bronwyn when she learned of his lineage. This leads Sauron to offer Theo a Ring of Power all his own.
Where can I send Feedback for The Rings of Power Season 3?
Once you've watched the episodes you can email us to feedback@tvpodcastindustries.com, you can message us @TVPodIndustries on Threads or join our Facebook group at https://facebook.com/groups/tvpodcastindustries or join us on our Discord server at https://discord.gg/DyVtkuuWZP and share your thoughts in our spoiler posts for each episode.
Made Possible with Patreon
TV Podcast Industries is made possible by our supporters on Patreon. You can follow and support us here: https://www.patreon.com/tvpodcastindustries
Next Time On TV Podcast Industries...
Thanks for joining us for our podcast all about The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 1 and 2. We will be back next time with our podcast all about The Rings of Power Season 3 Episode 3 "The Secret Fire" and Episode 4 "Gundabad".
Thanks so much for joining our circle fellow Ringers we hope to see you again soon.
Keep watching, Keep Listening and Keep sailing for The West.
John, and Derek
TV Podcast Industries
All images and audio clips are copyright of Prime Video and their respective copyright owners. The intro music for our Rings of Power Podcast is an edit of Humanity and our outro is an edit of Cinematic Trailer both by Scott Holmes Music and used under Creative Commons attribution 4.0 license
[00:00:00] This is the Lord of the Rings Podcast on TV Podcast Industries. We are back to The Rings of Power with Season 3, Episode 1, Marnuk and Episode 2, The Gift of Men. I told Sauron never to seek me out west I'm in the mountain. Dwarves cannot abide trespassers. And the Dark Lord cannot abide those who betray their promises.
[00:00:25] I need more time. The trap is set. I just need Durin to fall into it. And the Orc. Rivendell
[00:01:15] Welcome back fellow ringers to the Lord of the Rings Podcast on TV Podcast Industries. We are back after two years with The Rings of Power Season 3, Episode 1, Marnuk and Episode 2, The Gift of Men. I am one of your hosts, Derek. Hello there fellow ringers. Yes, I am also back after two years. I'm one of your other hosts, Jon. Welcome back to our Lord of the Rings Podcast here on TV Podcast Industries.
[00:01:42] Great to be back in the world of Middle-earth after this long. Now we've only been away for a couple of days if you listen to our regular podcast on TV Podcast Industries where we've been podcasting about Vision Quest and other TV shows. If you're not subscribed to the podcast over there, of course, pop to our website at tvpodcastindustries.com. But we are here for the return to Middle-earth in this massive production from Prime Video.
[00:02:05] Yes, we certainly are. But also one other aspect to inform our fellow listeners and fellow ringers for our coverage of this season of The Rings of Power. The podcast series is dedicated to my mum, Dorothy Harrison or Dottie. She absolutely adored The Lord of the Rings and was a massive fan of Peter Jackson.
[00:02:30] But she sadly passed away in July of this year at the age of 89 from Alzheimer's. But she also, in the early parts of that disease, we did introduce her to The Rings of Power, which she also absolutely enjoyed, along with The Hobbit series that Peter Jackson did as well. But Lord of the Rings was her bag.
[00:02:55] And so we would like to dedicate our coverage for season three of The Rings of Power to my mother, Dorothy Harrison. Absolutely. We love you, Dorothy. RIP. And I have to say, our intro music did get me welling slightly. It's really nice. It is. The intro music. It is, yes, yes. One of my favorites of our intros. Yes, yes. I think she would have been delighted by how this show starts.
[00:03:23] Seems to be hewing closer again to The Lord of the Rings. As we know, this show is based on The Lord of the Rings and the appendices by J.R. Tolkien. But getting closer again to the central themes of the story in this first couple episodes. Absolutely. And I have to say, as a geographer, I do like the old map work going on here. It gets very excited. Quite nice, yes.
[00:03:47] Not just paper catching on fire because of the evil Dark Lord, but also the kind of leather-bound version of the map as well that you see. That was a cool idea, wasn't it? Yeah, very nice. And also, I think whilst we aren't doing a pub quiz, so sorry about that, fellow quizzers and fellow ringers, I did think it would have been great if we were, we would have to call it the Wunderbar from Gundabad. Or Gundabad, in fact.
[00:04:17] Absolutely. We'd have to slightly mash that up. But sadly we're not. Not this time, but we could say it every week if you wanted. I think we should. I do quite like it. The Wunderbar from Gundabad. Yes, I like it. Yes, no pub quiz on this one, but we will be getting into all of our thoughts, all of our deep thoughts on these first two episodes of Rings of Power Season 3. They did release four episodes this week, and they'll be releasing two episodes each week until it gets to the end of the series. Really dropping this quite quickly on Prime Video.
[00:04:46] I was reading Russell T. Davis' book about television recently, and he was saying, Honestly, inside the industry, they have no idea what the best way to drop TV shows is, whether TV shows have to all be released at exactly the same time around the world, whether every episode has to be released on the same day, whether it's one episode a week. Nobody has figured it out at all. That's why everything is such a mess, because everybody's trying to work out what's best for each individual show, not even for their channel or for their service.
[00:05:14] So that's why we see with Prime Video, sometimes you get all eight episodes in one day, sometimes you get two starting out the season, then one a week. This time we're getting four episodes in the first week, two in the second week, and two in the third week, and that's the full season gone for another three years. I mean, I guess I kind of hear what he's saying there a bit, and I guess whilst I'm sure Prime, Netflix, certainly Disney+, would argue against what I'm about to say,
[00:05:41] I would inherently believe it's because they don't understand the notion of curating an art form, whether it be, for example, like librarians with books in libraries, or whether it is sort of gatekeepers of film, TV, artwork, you name it. It's about curation, and I do believe that if you really wanted to curate a show, you would give it the time for that discussion.
[00:06:10] Even if it was dropping it every three or four days, every half a week or something. But I think that's the reason for weekly shows, because anyone who wants to watch it in one big splash can do it once they've all been released. But anyway, I would say it's the lack of curation ultimately. Do you remember arguing that point before, and someone who likes to binge was going, no, no, I want everything immediately so I can talk about it. I have the time to watch it all just because you don't have the time to watch it all.
[00:06:40] That's your decision. No, no, I don't agree with that. But yeah, we have to. I think you can do it in multiple ways, but I think initially it's not about time. It's about giving it to breathe, to think on what's being provided, and to talk about it. And yes, absolutely, you can do it. I mean, this whole idea of binging multiple episodes came from DVD box sets back in the day. And then Netflix promoted it that way.
[00:07:09] Yeah, and then Netflix promoted it that way. But ultimately, that's because people who didn't see it, and they could binge it. I'm not saying any way is right or wrong, but I think ultimately the reason why studios have a problem on how to do it is because actually I think there's a real issue around curation of art form from these streaming services, which are primarily established for profit these days. Exactly.
[00:07:38] And all I know is it's worse for us because we get four episodes of this really, really dense show all dropping on the same day. And that's a lot and lots to watch, lots and lots to take in. And once we're finished the eight episodes, it's going to be two years before it returns to the fourth season. So it's going to be quite a long time after a really condensed period of watching this. But the argument would be that that's similar to when one of the Lord of the Rings movies dropped. You saw the three-hour movie, and then you could watch that over and over again until the next movie dropped. Absolutely agreed. Yeah.
[00:08:07] But release it on a Saturday or a Friday. Yeah, not on a Wednesday on the same day of the finale of Vision Quest came as well. But we'll only be talking about these two episodes. We'll talk about the other two in our next podcast. We're hoping to keep the frequency quickly enough so that we'll be able to catch up with the release schedule on Prime Video. And we hope to hear from you as well about each of the episodes. You can email us to feedback at tvpodcastindustries.com with your thoughts on any of the episodes as you watch them.
[00:08:35] If you're watching ahead, just make sure you mark the number of the episodes you're sending the feedback about. But you can also join us over on our Facebook group at facebook.com slash groups slash TV Podcast Industries, where there's a spoiler post for each episode there. Or you can join us on our Discord. The details of the Discord are in our show notes right here, or pop on over to Discord and look for TV Podcast Industries. We have a spoiler post for each episode up there now for the four episodes released so far of Rings of Power. Absolutely.
[00:09:00] Shall we get into our spoiler-filled discussion of Episodes 1 and 2 of this Rings of Power Season 3? Mm-hmm. Absolutely. Derek, give us the what, where, when, how, and why. Well, the show is based on The Lord of the Rings and the appendices by J. R. R. Tolkien. The showrunners for the show are J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay, the showrunners of the previous two seasons as well. They continue in that role for this season. That's a constant theme as we go through the directors and writers of this show.
[00:09:29] If you weren't happy, what was delivered in the first two seasons of The Lord of the Rings, The Rings of Power? Well, you're hell out of luck because it's all the same people involved in the next couple of seasons. The only thing that's changed, as far as I can see, is that they've moved location from New Zealand to the U.K. for filming. But you can't really tell because we're in a fantasy world. So the backgrounds, I think they filmed a lot of them and are using those backgrounds still while filming in the U.K.
[00:09:53] But the executive producers for the show are Lindsay Weber, Justin Doble, Charlotte Branstrom, and Kate Hazel with co-producer Andrew Lee. Episode 1 and Episode 2 were both directed by Charlotte Branstrom, who's directed loads of episodes of Rings of Power. She does all the big episodes of Rings of Power, so back here for the first two of this season. And Episode 1 was written by the showrunners, J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay. Episode 2 was written by Justin Doble, who's written seven of nine episodes of the season, of all the seasons, sorry. So seven of the nine episodes that have come out so far.
[00:10:23] So he's heavily involved in the show. Good stuff. Mm-hmm. Yes, I like it. And John, as we're going to cover two episodes, do you want to give us the episode synopsis for Episode 1, Marnuk, followed by the synopsis for Episode 2, The Gift of Men? Sure. Five years after the fall of Eregion and the death of Celebrimbor, Sauron's orc armies cover most of Western Middle-earth.
[00:10:46] Their progress has been halted on both sides by Lindon and Rivendell, where the uncorrupted Elven Rings of Power block his progress. Obsessed with gaining control of the rings, the Dark One toils in his forge at Barad-dûr to create one ring to rule them all.
[00:11:03] Unsuccessful, he also persuades mortal men, including Kamul al-Vrun, to become his ring servants or Naznagul, where they are gifted a ring of power in exchange for their complete devotion to Sauron. Meanwhile, in Khazad-dûm and the Mines of Moria, King Durin IV secretly armors the elven army through his alliance with Elrond.
[00:11:27] But the dwarves will not claim a side in the war. A rogue orc named Marnuk arrives at the mines, declaring he has a message for the elf Galadriel that could change their fortunes in the war against the Dark Lord. Elsewhere, in Pelargir, Theo and his people are enslaved, cutting down forests and decimating their lands to support Kemen and the Númenoreans.
[00:11:51] But when Kemen discards an invite from Sauron for a ring of power, Theo picks it up instead. And we see that play out in episode two? Yes, the Gift of Men. Across the Sundering Seas in Númenor, High King Ar-Pharazan is attacked by an assassin from the Faithful, shown to be Isildur. In their investigation into the attack, they vow to destroy the Faithful in their havens on the western shore.
[00:12:18] Isildur, helped by his sister Eareon, uses a palantir to warn his father Elendil. Meanwhile, at the same time, Farazan's suspicions uncovers the Faithful spy of all these years, Eareon. To avoid helping the illegitimate regent, Eareon walks off a balcony to her death. Back in the mines of Moria, King Durin's brother Thrain arrives.
[00:12:44] After concerns that he would usurp the throne, Thrain bends the knee and defends Durin against any challenge. This includes two Naznagul who try to force Durin to join the forces of Mordor. Later, Thrain secretly meets with the Naznagul, admonishing them for coming to him in Khazagdum when he has already set the track for his brother as he agrees with Sauron.
[00:13:07] In Rivendell, the orc informant Marnuk convinces Galadriel and Arondir to travel to the orc prison of Gundabad to rescue the last remaining elven smith from Eareon, who holds the knowledge of Celebrimbor, and to prevent Sauron gaining the remaining secrets that will help him create the One Ring. Meanwhile, in Barad-dûr, Sauron perverts Theo.
[00:13:33] After forcing him to battle to the death with his kinsmen, he informs Theo that his father was once a protector and nobleman of Mordor, which is why Theo held such a strong connection to Sauron's weaponry. He shares that his father was murdered by his mother, Bronwyn, when she learned of his lineage. This leads Sauron to offer Theo a Ring of Power all of his own. Oh, we are certainly back in Lord of the Rings of Power, aren't we?
[00:14:01] Lots of amazing characters, lots of names that we haven't spoken out loud in quite a few years. So, lots of interest and intrigue across these two episodes. Oh yeah, absolutely. There's some really interesting stuff here, which I'm sure must have been fascinating in the writer's room and the showrunner's room, and between rooms indeed, sort of thinking through how certain things may come about.
[00:14:29] And I guess some interesting choices, which probably come to across our five tales from these two episodes. But yeah, I think just some really good stuff here. And again, just the opening theme here, I've been humming it to myself for most of the week.
[00:14:49] It's so good how Howard Shaw has captured Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings work that he did in this, and how Ben McQuarrie as well, kind of with the music, sort of builds and layers this in. So, really, I think the whole musical side of this is really, really interesting. Gorgeous, absolutely gorgeous show as well. The production is incredible. That opening of the second episode, actually, where they come into Numenor,
[00:15:19] and we have the parade of Farazhan and his men through the city of Numenor, seeing sides of what we've never seen before. And even at the end of episode two, where we see the massive scope of Numenor now, it's absolutely beautiful. It seems like they've put even more money into this season, and every season has looked incredible before now. Maybe it's just a different views of the place. Yeah, it's interesting, isn't it? And maybe it's just the scale that's presented,
[00:15:45] but I feel as though Numenor as an island in the Sundering Sea is bigger. I have no sort of basis for that, other than they've shown elements of other parts of the island of Numenor. I think the first two kind of series, I guess it felt a bit like the Isle of Wight or the Isle of Man or something like that, or maybe Jersey, one of the Channel Islands. But now it feels more like it's a Madagascar or something, or Sri Lanka.
[00:16:15] It just feels something a little bit bigger. It does. A little bit more major. And I think that's probably because they compare Mordor's approaches to both Rune in the east, the vast desert kingdom or lands of Rune, and also there is Numenor on the horizon for Mordor as well. So I guess that makes it feel a little bit bigger,
[00:16:44] even though they're not comparable in size. I don't know why that matters, and it probably doesn't, but it felt like Numenor was more centrally placed within this world a bit, rather than just being an offshore island where there were a bit of a spear in the side, or a thorn in the side of the Dark Lord. I'm not saying I've not loved the Numenorans. That's not what I mean. I think they've scaled it. I think they have.
[00:17:12] I think that's probably a lot of it, yeah. This season really telling some of the stories that it's going to be telling. You know, it needs to have big, vast separation between some of the people. We've heard mention of it a bit in season one and two, where we had Elrond's brother lives somewhere in Numenor, but we don't see him at all. So we have people traversing across the size of the place, but it's not really shown on screen.
[00:17:36] Whereas here, you can really see there's areas of Numenor that are far away from other areas. But even the whole city of Numenor, the central area there seems vastly larger in scale than what we've seen in the past. It feels like something that would match with Gondor and Lord of the Rings, or Helm's Deep even. You know, that kind of size of a place is what it feels like. Or Barad-Dor, one of the big locations now. So they've definitely upped their game.
[00:18:05] It's probably because we're now spending more time there. We had the Numenoreans in Middle-earth for a lot of season two. This season starting off with them here in their own town, and we're hearing all about them in their lands and what they're doing. And it feels like we're going to be staying there a lot more. So might as well up it if we're going to spend more time there, huh? Yeah. But let's get into our Tales of Middle-earth, our five major moments or major points about these two episodes that we'll discuss as we go through.
[00:18:33] So our first tale really has to be It's Been Five Years of War. The opening of the episode tells us what's happened since the battle between Galadriel and Sauron, where Sauron finally got his hands on the rings for men and disappeared off into Mordor. Since that time, Mordor has spread its lands out across all of Middle-earth as far as it can get. And we have this amazing, I think, voiceover work from Galadriel,
[00:19:00] who is explaining how the borders of Mordor have been spreading across all of the continent until they get to Lindon on one side and the newly established city of, or newly established Elven homeland of Rivendell on the other, blocking out the power of Mordor because they have the untainted Elven rings, which are allowing them to stop Sauron and his army from arriving into their lands. Yes, absolutely.
[00:19:29] Really enjoy this kind of overview. Useful to have, you know, five years after Eregion was destroyed, we have, like you say, the powers of protection of these three Elven rings because they didn't actually involve Sauron's involvement. They were all produced without him and purely, you know,
[00:19:55] so in a sense these are the purest versions of these rings of power. And you then have the seven dwarf rings, which, you know, so far are out of Sauron's influence because simply Durin is not allowing people to wear them. He saw the corrupting influence of these rings on his father. And, of course, that did have Sauron's experimentation
[00:20:24] alongside Calumbrimbor sort of forging them. So I like the fact that the dwarves ultimately, you know, in some ways are being protected here by the decisions of Durin. And then, as you say, the nine rings for men have come back into Sauron's grasp. And he is slowly going through the different sort of kingdoms
[00:20:51] and regions of men across Middle-earth, of which the two main kingdoms left to kind of pick sides seem to be Numenor and Rune. And so, yeah, I really kind of, this is a really nice way of kind of getting us back into and getting our teeth sunk into the rings of power. I think also then a nice little moment here early on, and as we're talking about five years ago,
[00:21:21] why not talk about thousands of years ago with the old war between elves and orcs as well? And here, because we get to meet Celeborn as well. Yes, we do. Galadriel's husband, ultimately, the founder of Lothlorien, like we see in The Lords of the Rings. But I think this is really interesting little aside
[00:21:48] to bring in Celeborn here, played by Jamie Campbell Bower, who was in Stranger Things. He was Vakna in Stranger Things. So a much more lighter side here, I think. Yes, yeah. He brings the love into the show. You know, I think there was some interesting criticism. There's always criticism from Lord of the Rings fans to everything that rings the pair to. And last season, we had Galadriel kissing Elrond as a distraction.
[00:22:17] And suddenly, Lord of the Rings fans are up in arms going, but where's Celeborn, her husband? She's in love with him. There's no way she would kiss anybody else, whatever. Anyway, we have finally got the introduction of Celeborn, and it is shown exactly as it would be for Galadriel. She is completely in love with Celeborn from the moment she meets him. They have the beautiful moment of the dance through the forest. I love that she's slightly embarrassed by the fact that she's dancing in the forest and goes, oh, no, I was just here sparring as she picks up her sword.
[00:22:46] And he kind of goes, well, you know, sparring's probably better with two rather than just one. So yes, I don't think he believes for a second that she was doing any kind of sparring in there. But she is great with the blade, and they do have the romantic dance-off with a sword, which I thought was beautifully filmed. It really reminded me of Shang-Chi, the kind of meeting of Shang-Chi's parents in that, which I thought was, again, magical just as they're dancing
[00:23:15] and moving through the air like you couldn't possibly move. You weren't a magical creature like the elves. Yeah, and it was nice and thwippy, shall we say. I don't know. I kind of like that sort of notion of it being... It was almost, yeah, it felt like a dance rather than a full-on spa, even though you just get a little bit of a lock of her hair. He does, a little reminiscent of Gimli in The Rings. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so I thought that was quite good. And she says, you know, you can keep it.
[00:23:43] I like the fact that they kind of show this nascent Lothlorian, which I thought was really cool because the big tree, which you see in Lord of the Rings, you do see the younger version of that, or I felt that was really sort of obvious from the vista that they're looking out on, but the rest of the forest hasn't really established. It's not matured. And you see, but you hear Calivorn when he's talking to Galadriel saying, and then we could put some canopies over there
[00:24:13] and we could build some platforms that would go around here. You know, he's giving his full description of what Lothlorian would look like in a few thousand years. Yeah. And, you know, this turns to their discussion, which is why Galadriel is having the flashback. Celeborn is talking to her about all of these future plans, asks her to marry him. And she says, but there's war going on. And he says, there will always be war, but this is forever. The love that they have will go on regardless of the wars.
[00:24:42] So I love this way of introducing Celeborn. As this story progresses, we don't know where Celeborn is. We haven't seen him in the present day at all throughout the last couple of series. We will see him in the future and in the next major time that we've seen in Lord of the Rings. But I wonder, will they bring him in to the story later on in the season? Yeah. I mean, I'm sure they will do. Otherwise, it feels a little odd introducing him here. I mean, what I did like here as well as I liked,
[00:25:10] as she says, yes, I will to him about after he's asked her to marry him. It transitions, you know, her face transitions to the present day were exactly, to quote his words, they're fighting orcs still in the present day war against them. Yeah. Sort of being attacked by westerlings. So I just thought that was kind of, it just carried through Celeborn's words from that earlier time into the present.
[00:25:40] And speaking of the dance, you know, the duet here between Arondir and Galadriel as the two of them battle the orcs between each other, I thought was so cool. We had the, you know, Arondir kicking an orc across towards Galadriel as she takes him out. I think it's excellent. And then, yes, it stretches into the westerlings attacking after the orcs disappear. The fight continues. And we learn over these five years of war,
[00:26:08] Arondir is starting to really face, issues with how violent he has been and how many people he's killed over the course of this war. He kills one of the westerlings who, as he dies, looks like he has the face of Theo. And initially, Arondir is terrified that he may have killed Theo. He killed this person so offhandedly, or out of hand, as he wouldn't have done in the past. He would always have gone after the orcs, I suppose, in the past, but not.
[00:26:38] Now the men are attacking. He's now killing people that are like people that he would have trusted in the past. So I love seeing that little change in Arondir and seeing how the war is affecting him. There's a really nice kind of moment in the second episode in Rivendell where Galadriel's had that ill dream, and she's sort of woken up and she's kind of getting some air in Rivendell and she bumps into Arondir,
[00:27:06] who also seemingly has had an old dream around Theo. Why are you awake? Well, I could be asking you why you were awake. No, exactly. And I love how later in this first episode, you have, you know, Galadriel saying, you know, that her thoughts are infected, you know, seemingly reinfected with visions of Sauron, these little dreams. But she says to Arondir, who's there, says, you know,
[00:27:34] why is it easier that these secret pains can hide, we can hide them in daylight? But Arondir, I think, with his aspects around Theo, you know, he goes, if I hadn't failed. So the other side of it is he feels like he's failed his duty to men. He says, if I hadn't failed in my duty to the men of Middle-earth, maybe these men and boys would not have swords in their hands fighting for Sauron. Because we do, you know,
[00:28:04] we see Galadriel trying to sort of comfort him by saying, well, you've not put the swords in their hands, but he's kind of like, well, maybe we did because we were the ones that ultimately allowed or weren't on the ball to prevent this from happening. You know, so I kind of, I liked how that kind of plays through a little bit later on in this episode as well. Absolutely. Absolutely. Last bit of this really
[00:28:31] is just the addition now of Rivendell, which looks incredible. After these five years, last season, we saw them picking the location for it effectively. And this season, we see them coming into Rivendell. We have lots of the elves actually living in Rivendell, which is great. And also, these are hidden locations, hidden by magic. So, it's not like they just have a force feel around them. Effectively, anybody who tries to search out where they are will be turned around
[00:29:00] by the magic that's there. So, they will not be able to penetrate the outer regions of Rivendell. So, what it looks like to everybody else, and I like how it was presented here, what it looks like to everybody else is when someone crosses the threshold, they just disappear completely. So, that's quite cool. So, we have Galadriel running away from the Naznagul and disappearing in front of them. So, that was a great way of doing it. So, yes, so it's the protection around those two big lands. So,
[00:29:29] that's why they can't be attacked. I think that's it for the five years of war, the opening of the episode and the setup for the season, really. Let's get into some more of the more detailed points of the season with our tale two, The Forge of Barad-dûr. Yeah, I mean, this is really interesting. There's a number of things here that sort of caught my eye, just because it's the seat of Sauron's power. I think one of the most grisly and gruesome is that you have
[00:29:59] Kel and Brimbo as almost an ornament hanging on the wall in the forge here. Very gruesome, very brutal. And what I kind of like that they bring out here is despite all his power in Kel and Brimbo's death that he's kind of haunting Sauron here. He's attacking him for not having all the knowledge because what we see is him starting
[00:30:28] the attempt to create the one ring that will bind all the others to it. Although, I will say by the reaction of all of the orcs in the room, that's definitely done his first attempt and lots and lots of orcs have died in his attempts to create the ring. Agreed. I have to say... All of them with their heads down looking at the floor don't make eye contact. Well, initially as well. I thought actually it was a kind of slight moment of lightness really because yes, they're all trying to averse
[00:30:58] his gaze and I thought that was because of his power. Yeah, okay. And actually it's because yes, they've seen it before and the unfortunate orc that does put it on looks like it's okay and then his hand spontaneously combusts and bursts into flames puts it out and then the bucket of water bursts into flames with his hand and now his arm. I do like the fact that he gets very, very crispy very, very quickly. It does. But I think it speaks
[00:31:27] to another point. Well, firstly, I just, again, I like the orcs. It was kind of that, I don't know, screams can be blood curdling. They can also be sometimes a little slightly amusing. I did find this slightly amusing but in a good way. I'm not having a go. I actually just thought like the look of the orc was genuinely, oh my God, it's doing it and the high-pitched scream, you know,
[00:31:56] we can't all be cool when we're suddenly faced with our mortality. So I just thought this was really, really well done and I think, but I think it also then speaks to another point and it is, I guess, the title of episode one which is Marnuk because I think what we find seeping in here through these failed attempts on the rings, also potentially his treatment of the orcs is some resentment like the unfulfilled promises
[00:32:25] that Sauron has given. I mean, we do hear Sauron talking disparagingly about the orcs, you know, in order to get his own way. Whether he believes that or not, he is happy enough to portray them as the terrorizers of Middle-earth even though it's at his command and give that separation between the orders he gives and the people that do it which are the orcs. But here with Marnuk,
[00:32:55] certainly later, we may be here from him, this ring that is being created will be as much of a problem for his people, the orcs, because we will just be food for his enemies, you know, in battle as much as it will be for the elves. But here you have him standing up almost, almost not like confronting Sauron and approaching him quite head-on. And I have to say,
[00:33:24] I thought here it was kind of really interesting because I was expecting him to die straight off the bat. But Marnuk wants to be the orc who wins the war, who wins all the wars if they're able to get the elven rings and also to get the knowledge and the secrets that elude Sauron from Kellen Brimble. So here you have Marnuk sort of offering him up to be the one to do this, but it felt
[00:33:53] in a challenging way. It did. And not just simply a subservient way. Yeah. So I really like that and I did think it was 50-50 as to whether he would come out of this. And it feels like, you know, the presence of Adar or that, it still persists within the orcs. I think it does. The father who would have brought them peacefully to safety to their own homeland. And here they're still, you know, I think the concern
[00:34:22] for Marnuk is that it'll be perpetual war. But again, I'm also wondering to what extent is Marnuk a red herring here as well? Is he playing both sides or just one? Yeah. And which one is that? Is it Sauron or is it the elves? Well, they seem to be very well convinced as we learned by the end of the second episode. They seem to be very well knowledgeable about what Marnuk's doing, certainly. So you're right. I do think there's an element
[00:34:51] of what Adar's legacy that was left behind in there with Marnuk. That's why he's standing up almost as if they are still fighting side by side with Sauron instead of completely subservient to him, which is quite interesting. And also in the the taunting from Celebrimbor in that vision that he has, Celebrimbor says to him, you'll never achieve your goal. The work isn't in you and the orcs are starting to pity you.
[00:35:19] So what it feels like is this is kind of the last ditch effort of one of the orcs to show that they can be as useful to Sauron as the humans are. So maybe they could deserve one of the rings of power themselves. Yeah. And if this fails, then Celebrimbor will turn them into subservient, completely just his tools to accomplish his goals. That's what it feels like. This is like a last ditch effort of Marnuk to do this. That's true. I really enjoyed Kellan Brimbor's
[00:35:48] sort of stalking of Sauron here. The other thing he says, which is always useful as a reminder just to, you know, say, okay, Sauron, you know, is pretty dark and despicable. But he says, you know, we were never partners. There's a piece of machinery missing from your soul which one which can't find empathy with people. It can only find and look to master control over others.
[00:36:17] So, you know, That is literally what the one ring is. It's control and mastery over all other rings. So, I love that aspect from Kellan Brimbor. So, yeah, the Forge of Baradur here, we do see it briefly from the outside. So, it's still kind of, it feels like it's still being built. It's under construction. Under construction. The massive tower is about half the size that it needs to be to carry the eye of Sauron on the top of it at a later stage.
[00:36:47] But really cool to see it a little being inside this iconic location. If you looked at the making of afterwards as a short little two or three minutes on Prime Video, they talk about the fact that it's modeled on the forge of Kellan Brimbor as well. So, because of the jealousy of Sauron for what Kellan Brimbor was able to accomplish, the actual location itself in Baradur that forge that he's built mirrors pretty much the shape of Kellan Brimbor's forge.
[00:37:17] Which I think is cool. So, it's just a dark version of the forge. Yeah. So, hoping that if he makes the shape of it, he'll also be able to make the ring the way that Kellan Brimbor was able to. So, I thought that was quite cool. Yeah. Excellent stuff. Shall we get into our tale number three? Yes, we shall. The Naz Nagul. Well, I think my notes on these are it's just really cool to see this. And I think certainly for me, it is about those choices. You know, from I think Peter Jackson's you get the sense
[00:37:46] of the nine ring bearers from the race of men being, you know, the kings of old and so on. What we hear is a little bit more of a muckier, dirtier way of getting your hands or finger on the ring. Uh-huh. And I kind of think that's an interesting choice. Oh, yeah. Ultimately, you know, it's not, there's not a pageantry element to this. This is an all-out survival
[00:38:14] in order to live in the first instance but also to show complete devotion and loyalty to Sauron and not, in some cases, like in the case of the Kingdom of Rune, the Dark Wizard that we saw from Season 2. And I kind of like how this fight plays out as well. Just from the beginning, you know, the delegation here who arrived from Rune, they're standing in front of Sauron
[00:38:44] and they're going, you know, basically, now that we've got all of our armies combined together under the Dark Wizard, we're willing to join up with you, you know, basically fight side by side alongside you with Dark Wizard as our leader and you as the leader of the Orcs. And Sauron kind of throws down immediately at that, going, well, how, how dedicated are you to this leader of yours? The leader of the delegation from Rune goes, what do you think? That's the way to see how trustworthy we are or how trusting we are
[00:39:14] to challenge our leader immediately and he is killed immediately by one of the Orcs. And I love that two of them are killed before it gets on to what the choice that Sauron makes, which is, I will throw a sword down for you and the only one of you that lives and there will only be one will get a ring effectively. Well, that's it. I mean, I kind of really liked this idea that it feels a little right because it's always that the hearts of men were easily turned
[00:39:44] and it's that even these delegations, the hearts of men can turn against their, the loyalty to their own leader. And so I kind of really enjoyed that notion of it. But I think as well, as Sauron says, you know, the proposed alliance was not for the Dark Wizard, but for you, you know, you five lords who used to rule these lands, but actually he gets them down to three suitors only,
[00:40:13] but he uses the line of, but these are but precious gifts and Mordor can only sure, but one of one this day. And so yeah, you have the fight and you see that again when the kinsmen from Pelagir arrive as well. He uses the same process in order to get them to fight. So I kind of like that because it felt more scrappy
[00:40:43] and it feels like it undermines the regal-ness of the kings and so on. Well, it's something that we see across the last couple of seasons of the show and many different fantasy shows. We see the traveling of the regions from different lands coming to pay homage to the new leader. Here we have, as you say, five kings from Rune coming in. They must have traveled together. They must have known each other for years. They must have a whole history
[00:41:13] together. And here they are, stored in front of them. Only one of you can live and the one who lives gets to control all of the lands and must be subservient to me. And again, with Theo from Pellargeir, he's effectively going there to look for help from Sauron to fight back against the Numenoreans alongside five other full-grown men from his home that he probably has known all of his life. And everybody there is being told, only one of you walks out alive and the one that does will be my servant. Amazing
[00:41:43] choice to do it this way and really dynamic and really aggressive. Absolutely. And really what we can see from this as well is at least Camul of Rune the furthest of the Naznagul, I think Sauron calls him. Interesting choice. Yeah, it is. It seems to be maybe the third of the Naznagul. So we also see that from the kingdom of Lossoth the king there. And that's the interesting thing to me
[00:42:13] is, is it the fact that for Rune and Numenor in a sense they've spurned the advances so far? Now, I mean, even Numenor still is. And there is a really interesting thing around the strategy of Farazan. But, which we'll come to in our next tale, of course, but you also have Harad as well. And I'm like, are these the kings that immediately came to the aid of
[00:42:42] Mordor and to Sauron? And so the kings were granted the rings for men. But here the king isn't even showing up. So he's flipping it. He's using it against them. And I think that's the same possibility with theory. So I really like this. I also like that the elves are aware of these Dasnagul. You hear Elrond and Galadriel talking that
[00:43:12] the king of Lothsof has been turned. They've lost them as an ally and that they need to start making allies. It seems like they're losing a lot of allies here. And a lot of elves as well in all the battles. Yeah, Lothsof turned up at that battle, at the end of the battle with the elves and the orcs and the westlings. He arrived. The only reason I mention it is just because it really did feel like the ring rates from Lord of the Rings,
[00:43:41] but even more dynamic because he's a lot younger. He's not fully turned. He's just a human with a mask on his face and the ring on his hand. But I love where he picks up the orc and throws him at Galadriel to get her off her horse. He takes out the horse by throwing an orc. He's just using everything around him, including the power he has in his ring. But that's where she disappears into the forest to get away from him because she probably wouldn't have survived that battle one-on-one with the Nazna Ghoul. Well, I mean, what comes very apparent here is that
[00:44:10] the Nazna Ghoul are very formidable opponents. I mean, even against Galadriel, she seems to be sort of in survive mode in this fight with him. He warns her that they're coming for the Elven Rings and it's interesting, they are told that Monouk has gone to Rivendell later on by Thrain. So, it will be interesting to see how that magic holds up. But at least in this moment, that magic
[00:44:39] does allow Galadriel to escape what could be seen as a certain capture, at least. I mean, hugely formidable opponents. I love the joust elements that they have there and he just picks up one of the soldiers, the orc soldiers, and throws it at the feet of her horse. So, yeah, it's all really, really cool. I think we do need to shout out with the other Nazna Ghoul
[00:45:08] that accompanies Lossoth as well. is Harad, mainly because they do take off their masks here. And so we see that they're not wraiths at this stage, even though they can pretty much withstand an elephant dagger in the arm and so on. The power of these rings here that Sauron talks to certainly Camul about is this notion that you are living in this world
[00:45:38] and another and your body is having to get used to that but it clearly heals his hands and repairs his face that's been hidden behind their own masks previously. So, you know, they're very hardy, very indestructible these Nazna Ghoul. I don't know whether you got this from when you watched John, but this really felt like, you know, they were being given vampire power almost. It's like they were being fully cured and becoming evil and
[00:46:07] they were going to live in eternity as well. So, everything that's happening in this scene where we see Camul get the ring, it looks like he's being healed. Yes, that's a positive thing, but everything else about it is your heart will be turned and you will live in two worlds, the world of the afterlife and existing in the present Middle Earth. That's quite well explained in Lord of the Rings where we see Frodo put on the ring for the first time around a ring wraith and he sees them looking
[00:46:36] completely different inside that second world, the world he goes to when he has the ring on, the invisible world, or the hidden world, I suppose, which I think is the other side of that we see when we get to Lord of the Rings. I love how this is done in here. The last thing is Harrod that accompanies Lossoth is played by Cyril Neary who was in Cucumber. It was great to see him there, great that they could remove their masks and have that moment for the two actors.
[00:47:06] It was really good there. absolutely. Love Cyril Neary and Cucumber had a fantastic role in there. It's so great to see him getting a role here in Rings of Power. Lots of great actors appear on this show just for little moments. We'll talk about one major actor that gets a role this season in one of our later points. We obviously have to talk about the other potential Nazna Ghul here, Theo. Let's talk a little bit about what happens to Theo in this episode. There is the five-year time jump, so Theo
[00:47:36] has grown up quite a bit since the last time we saw him, left on the shores of Palagir when Numenor came in and took over the area and started to cut down all the trees in the area in spite of the arrangement they made with the Ents to protect those lands. Now we have effectively it all being scoured for fuel for the warfires of Numenor. Yes, for their fleet that they're creating. The ships
[00:48:06] of course. I think it's also they happen to be doing all this under the watchful eye of Kemen, Farazan's son, which is just the worst person. What I like about this is the unintended consequences. He gets 12 lashes here, which seems fairly obnoxious from the Numenoreans for having a slight break.
[00:48:35] I don't think they necessarily thought that they were going to be put almost to slave labor. But alas, here we have Theo taking up the discarded message to the Numenoreans from Sauron proposing an alliance and a ring of power. I kind of really enjoy here how Kemen, although I don't, you know, he's
[00:49:04] absolutely obnoxious, he talks about, well, I don't need a trinket. Like, he just dismisses it so much. It says like some person has come to town going, I've got some rings in the box. You want to give me five bucks, I'll be able to give you a nice ring. It's like the summons to Mordor, you know, who's this person peddling magic jewelry
[00:49:34] effectively? Just ignore it. But Theo doesn't. Oh, Theo sees an opportunity there, yes. I really kind of like this and how it plays out. Yeah, and it's interesting, I guess that's because of the experience that comes with living in Pelagir after the fall of Mordor or the creation of Mordor, right? So Theo has the knowledge of who Sauron truly is, whereas Kemen is coming from across the sea knowing that Sauron
[00:50:04] is effectively their future enemy but doesn't really know the lay of the land as it would be in Middle Earth. So Theo hearing that Sauron's handing out powerful rings, he's going, oh, I want me one of those, effectively. No, exactly. But I think as well, it's just Theo's arc is hugely interesting because he was the one that saw the hilt and the one that ultimately the hilt sort of created the mark on him. And I like that that comes back into play here
[00:50:34] with Sauron seeing it. So again, he comes forward to Sauron with a whole load of other people from around Pelagir. and they say straight off, you know, we're not Numenoreans. We're here to help you against the Numenoreans. But when Sauron, you know, Sauron does the usual Harry Hill
[00:51:03] fight moment that he needs to do. Which one of you is best? I saw this described in the synopsis on Wikipedia as a battle royale. Yes. It's like WWE. Yeah, exactly. they're right, but it's such a weird thing to describe it. Yeah. So I like that, you know, Sauron sees the mark left there and this really then intervenes effectively. He makes sure Theo
[00:51:33] wins. Five men enter, one Sauron comes in and aids one person that he wants to win the fight. Yeah. And I like then how he looks to influence, shape, and dare I say it, perverts Theo here in the talk of, you know, asking him where he got that mark from, what does he know about it, what does he know about his father, and so on. And I mean, for me, the standout bit here was when they start to
[00:52:02] talk, or at least that's how it's been portrayed by Sauron through the use of necromancy, talking to Theo's dead father called Thaldred, son of Hamathreg. Now, I just thought it was really nice, this is kind of like a little potted history, you know, when from a noble house of old, Gorthmundur, which was
[00:52:32] a sworn steward of Mordor, and that, you know, blessed with certain powers and a heritage that is passed from father explains, you know, why Theo was drawn to that hilt in season one. So all of this is being told to Theo by Sauron. So again, is it a false narrator? But Theo, in part, sort of does take it on. It's when it comes to the
[00:53:02] part where he says that Faldred was murdered by his mother, Bronwyn, tried to keep all this lineage from Theo. And that, you know, Theo does question, well, you're a murderer, you know, kind of just question Sauron here. And Sauron takes up almost another text. You can see him sort of gaming it out where he just says, you know, you have it
[00:53:31] in you to be a conqueror, a sorcerer, and a king, as Sauron offers, I guess, one of the bigger rings of men to Theo. And so, I mean, this begs the real juicy question as to whether he is the witch king of Angmar here. Sort of the premium Nazgul that is the leader of the Nazgul for Sauron.
[00:54:01] So, but I just think this is really good. And to be honest, I feel as though it makes sense for Theo to get captured in this lie or truth, whatever it is, to become a Nazgul. Like, you called it out really well in your description there, you know, one of the other names for Sauron is the necromancer. So, he is someone that is able to commune with the dead in a very evil way, is kind of the way it's always been portrayed in the past. So, him being
[00:54:30] able to commune with his father, with Theo's father, and get all of this information and relay it to Theo isn't beyond the bounds of possibility at all. Him using Theo's love for his mother is really important, because he says to him, you know, those people killed your mother, so that's why you should go after them. That's all really important, but interestingly, you're right, that moment where he says to him, Bronwyn killed your father when she found out who he was, that didn't sit well with Theo,
[00:55:00] so he changed tack quite quickly, but that's the thing that Sauron does quite often, is trying to find the things to prod and carry along, so yeah, have we seen the creation over the course of these three seasons of the leader of the Nazgul? Love it, love it, I think that's really interesting. I hope that's the story, really sad to lose Theo that way, of course, but we've always known there was something behind him, and to be honest, this is a narrative that would work very well
[00:55:30] in the a really long game being played with this one character coming from being a child at the beginning eventually becoming the leader of the Nazgul in the future, I think is a story to tell. Really enjoyed this. Two more episodes to find out? Absolutely. Six more episodes. Exactly. Shall we get into our tale number four, move on from the Nazgul to Deep in the Mines of Moria. Not as deep as last season. Not as
[00:56:00] deep as last season. More spiritually deep this time, because it's the kind of concern from Durin, who is now king of the dwarves in the Mines of Moria, that potentially his brother could be coming back to just take that throne out from underneath him. So we have a bit of pageantry going on. We finally get to meet Durin and Dees' children, who have been in the background for the last couple of seasons. They're both
[00:56:29] involved in waiting for the arrival of their uncle to the city. They are there to welcome other princes, other dwarven kings of other areas who arrive effectively to just get their hands on the rings that were promised to them by Durin's father. And then it turns out that Thrain, Durin's brother, won't be coming to the pageantry at all. He's going to go and get drunk with all of his old mates in the pub and wants Durin to come down to him.
[00:56:59] I think this is really good. It is. He comes with two of the blue lords, I guess from the blue mountains. They're in tow and it's this notion that is ever present for Durin that he's here to assert his claim on the throne that Durin has. I like that Deezer really does not trust his intentions
[00:57:29] at all. He has rings on his mind and actually in this moment where Thrain is deciding to laugh it up in one of the dwarven taverns in Khazak Doom. I love the joke of Navi having to go backwards and forward and slowly getting out of breath exhausted from the back and forth but it is Deezer that steps in to say enough of this bring eight barrels of the finest beer here close down the
[00:57:58] taverns and get him here Durin adds another two on but yeah she's the one that suggested and again I love that Darvey goes could somebody else go into that exactly but that is the thing that draws him out he does come in he does bend the knee
[00:58:28] to his brother and also pushes away the blue the blue lords who are trying to get their rings so Deesa says they're going to be compensated they're going to get all the money back but they contributed to Durin's father but they won't be getting the rings yeah absolutely I think it's good isn't it you have Thrain here admonishing the two lords here quite forthright stop your king has spoken
[00:58:58] and I like then it goes into a little bit of their father the boots with the squeaky clasps which was quite good but you have here Thrain saying you can trust me and Deesa really does not trust him I'm not buying
[00:59:28] his pish she says I think the two elements here is clearly Thrain thinks there was something between him and Deesa at some point which is caught by the grown up wean of Gamli so Gamli and Gerda are much older now I just really like the way that Gamli does his massive hair is really good no beard but massive hair he's the one doing the goat
[01:00:26] the description from Thrain that they had any kind of relationship prior to her and Durin getting together seems to be completely denied by Disa. But there's quite a significant hidden backstory with Thrain, isn't there? Durin felt that he was going to be just coming in and challenging him for the throne. It turns out he's working for Sauron. We have the arrival of the Mazdagool who are trying to tell Durin that because he has received the rings from Sauron,
[01:00:54] and therefore he now has to pledge his allegiances to the Mazdagool. And he effectively kicks them out, as does Thrain, until we see him meeting up with them afterwards saying, the plan is on track. I need time to put myself in place in the Mines of Moria in Khazad-dûm. And also tells them that Marnuk, the orc, is on his way to Rivendell as well as they go off to Rivendell to follow up on Marnuk, we think.
[01:01:23] Well, that's it. Yeah. I mean, I think the two interesting things here is, yeah, as you say, Thrain tells that the orc has gone to Rivendell. Also that whatever the trap that's been agreed is set, it just needs to be sprung by Durin. Yes. Not by the orc. No. It's also that, you know, Thrain does see Durin sword running for the elves, and they do have a fight.
[01:01:51] So that's the thing, he has embedded himself because that's where he, you know, in their fighting and rolling around on the ground, they roll to the feet of Marnuk, where he says, I have knowledge that could save Middle-earth. Really interesting point here is it then cuts to Gil-galad and Serlan, who also see the orc in their visions, and that they can't say what part
[01:02:18] for good or for ill he will play, but that he is there to shape the fortunes, you know, his actions will shape fortunes. So again, leaving this notion of is Marnuk, can he be trusted or not here? And really sort of to the fore here, which I like. It certainly adds something even more untrustworthy or more difficult to tell his intentions when
[01:02:47] the uncorrupted rings of the elves are sharing that this is an important orc that's just presented himself for them. Yeah, so it's a bit of a surprise actually when you find out that Thrain is fully aware of who Marnuk is and that the plan is there. He knows where he's been sent on to, and it seems like Sauron's fully aware of what's happened with Marnuk. So the thing at the forefront of their mind, the concerns that Duran and Deezer had is actually
[01:03:15] the thing that he, whilst Deezer is still hugely untrusting of Thrain, it's in a sense blindsided them to the plan that is in operation. And actually you see Duran sort of warming more to his brother, like even when Thrain, you know, in quite a tense standoff with the Nasna Ghul, you see him kind of
[01:03:41] being appreciative of what his brother has done there. I think, I know whilst we're in the mines of Moria or Khazad-dûm, we should just actually as well maybe mention that, you know, Marnuk does get to Rivendell and he, the big thing here is he tells them, he tells Elrond and Erondia and Galadriel that there is this forging of a master ring to make the others subordinate
[01:04:10] to the one ring. But that he doesn't have this knowledge or the secrets that Kellan Brimboe used in the crafting of the elven rings. And so, you know, this is what he's looking for. But he doesn't know that under his own nose in the big orc fortress and prison of Gundabad, there is a she-elf,
[01:04:39] as Manuk says, caught by himself. Mattel, the last of the elven smiths. And, you know, this is someone that they need to go and rescue so that that knowledge doesn't fall into Sauron's possession. Yeah, I was wondering whether this was the elven smiths that we saw back in Eregion,
[01:05:06] the one who created a ring that made them disappear. Because remember, there was that moment where someone was crashing around the forge and eventually they got the ring off them and they didn't really know that they had disappeared. So I wonder if that's the person that was able to get out of Eregion and then was captured by Marnuk after that battle or something like that. So I'd be interested to find out. I know we've got an episode coming up called Gundabad. So we obviously are going to get there at some point in the future. And
[01:05:34] whether that person is killed or whether Marnuk is going to be capturing her and taking her back to Sauron with the aid of Galadriel and Arandir, unknown to themselves, maybe that's the plan that they have. Absolutely. And I mean, the way Marnuk as well sort of phrases this is he's there to honour the promise of an allegiance between Adar and Galadriel. Because he does say that, you know, Sauron's
[01:06:02] plans are as much of, if not more of a threat to all kind as will just be food to his enemies. Exactly. And he sees that they don't hold anything special other than of being a fighting force to Sauron. So yeah, really kind of nice little intrigue here happening deep in the minds of Moria and of course in Rivendell as well. Absolutely. One thing we definitely should mention though is that Thrain is played by Eddie Marson. Yes.
[01:06:30] It's great to see him in this role. He's unrecognisable to me. I've seen him in so many movies, so many TV shows. I think he's completely unrecognisable. He looks like he's having lots of fun playing this sort of. I think so, yeah. He looks completely different. The beard obviously and the way the hair is great, but he's also a really forceful character, something that Eddie Marson tends not to play. He's been in stuff like The World's End where he's a much more shy, retiring kind of character and been
[01:06:58] in loads of shows as kind of the husband of someone or that kind of thing. So here as this fighting dwarf willing to throw down at any second is a really cool way to see him. So well done that's what an actor does, right? Yes, exactly. That's it for our fourth point. Let's get on to our final point, which is our final tale for Rings of Power Season 3, Episode 2, which is the Numenor machinations. I think this is
[01:07:26] a huge other side of what's going on in Middle Earth, another side of what's going on in Season 3 of Rings of Power. We talked about how beautiful the location is, but the story that's told here in Numenor after all of the battles that were going on for control and Al-Farazan finally becoming the High King, Muriel finally being taken off the board and put in prison. Actually, we hear after this five-year time jump that she's been broken out of prison, so she was
[01:07:53] put in prison. There's lots and lots of great stuff going on here that will play out, it seems, over the course of the season. We have The Faithful now effectively being the resistance movement against Farazan, but it seems like most of the Numenoreans are really on Farazan's side now because he's making them very, very wealthy with his war machine. And interestingly, of all of the characters that we've seen here, it's only really the elves that we've seen that
[01:08:21] are up against Sauron are fighting back against Sauron. Interestingly, the plan of Farazan is to create this army to take down Sauron. So he is an enemy of Sauron. He sees Sauron as being an enemy of Numenor and of the people of Middle Earth. So he's actually on the good side, if you want to say that, which is really interesting. Yeah, absolutely. That I really like. I mean, it's all for self-glorification of himself and
[01:08:47] Numenor. I think partly because the advisor here right at the start, just very, you know, during the kind of the coach ride where he's chucking money out and before Isildur's attempted assassination of him, his advisor, Belzagar, you know, just says, you know, why are we looking, you know, to build this armada, to chase a phantom from across the sea? And, you know,
[01:09:17] this Dark Lord Sauron, like he's questioning the strategy of Farazan. Yeah. And certainly given then soon after you have this attempt on his life. Yeah. But that's what I mean. I feel like it's Farazan who has the realization that Sauron is an enemy of Numenor. He has to be taken down. He's building his armies, but the advisor is telling him, Belzagar is telling him, well, why don't we rest our laurels here? We've got a pretty good, we've got, you know, all the women that we want.
[01:09:45] We've got all the alcohol we want. We've got all the food that we want. Our city is massively prosperous because of you being in the leadership role. Why would you throw it all away on this battle across the sea? And Farazan's kind of going, no, no, I think you're missing the point that we will lose everything if we don't take out Sauron. So it's quite interesting given that Farazan is an evil character from what we've seen in the last two seasons, that actually his focus is on taking out Sauron and seems to be the only person whose focus is taking out Sauron. So, you know,
[01:10:15] there's a real tale to be told here on how Numenor falls and how they go on the side of Sauron in the future. So let's see how it's going to play out. But seeing that we have the resistance led by Isildur in the city and some other hidden players, which plays out across this episode. And they're trying to take down the ruling class of Farazan and his people.
[01:10:43] Yes. I mean, what's interesting is this failed attempt by Isildur, his accomplice, Haleth, is captured. And this is where, you know, sort of post that assassination attempt, you've got Farazan sort of saying, well, this isn't Muriel's style. Is this the faithful in the West where there is the man with the white flame who is building her an army? You know,
[01:11:09] is it that he is coming? And you have this interrogation of Haleth by Iarian, who is considered to be, you know, this devout enforcer of Farazan's sort of ethos and rule. Well, she turned her back on her father and her brother and her friends to follow Farazan.
[01:11:33] A disciple, an ardent disciple, if you will. And she interrogates this faithful Haleth, where it then transpires that she is in fact, or has become over the last five years, this double agent working as a faithful inside the Farazan camp. And I like here that, like Haleth says, if only more of us could know about you and what you do. She tries to give him
[01:12:01] something that will help ease the pain, but he says, no, that could just make me cloudy and I might give something up. And so he sacrifices himself. Um, so her identity remains unknown and he doesn't want to risk, uh, anything here. And, um, you know, he's run through by swords when she comes out to say, well, I have a name from him. So I kind of really enjoyed, um, this double cross in a sense.
[01:12:30] Um, and I like how it kind of works through here where you have Balgazar almost sort of giving her little, um, snippets here, you know, that they're going to pursue the faithful and it will begin in the West. It feels very much like a purge here. Um, but he doesn't really give too much away from her. And of course she meets with Isildur to tell, uh, him about the death of Haleth, but also,
[01:12:59] um, you know, the faithful really now are, are not safe in the West because it's the havens of the faithful are going to be attacked. Um, so I don't know whether that's a kind of teeing up, but there are suspicions that come, um, to her and which get revealed later in this second episode by Farazhan.
[01:13:23] And it mainly comes from her handmaiden. You have a great scene with her and her handmaiden, sort of where she's putting sort of her, her makeup on and the, the two of them are reflected in the mirror. And it's almost kind of this dance of no, I'm an acolyte of Farazhan. I, I'm not a faithful. I would spit on them. I would, you know, I wouldn't have any concern for them. I wouldn't spit if they're on fire. Even if they're on fire. Exactly. Um, but ultimately the handmaiden gets killed as an
[01:13:53] informant at the word of Iarian. Um, so, and is sort of thrown to the gallows and partly this, uh, what we learn is that the handmaiden is the one that's come to Farazhan and Balsagar, um, about her suspicions that possibly information has been leaked by Iarian. Exactly. Exactly. And this really does have that feel of, um, great shows like Andor,
[01:14:21] um, you know, that, that's, uh, the machinations going on here, the, uh, the double crosses, the, um, the multiple players on different sides. Um, if you're going to steal from another project, steal from the best, right? So why not have this in here in, uh, in the rings of power? We, we know that there's always been back and forth between all the different sides and Numenor, uh, throughout the previous couple of seasons, but this is where it feels like resistance versus
[01:14:47] the, uh, versus the powers, uh, above every, every, uh, buddy. And they're using bait to get Iarian to reveal herself as the spy within their myths or they need, they need access to the Palantir so that Isildur can, uh, tell his father about this potential purge that's going to happen in the West, which is where Elendil is based now. Um, so they have to break in. The only way to
[01:15:11] get there is by stealing the, the key from Balzagar's quarters and he sees, uh, Iarian coming out of his quarters. So he knows that she's responsible. It was interesting just a little bit in the discussion where Farazan is finally revealing that they know that Iarian is the, uh, is the spy. Um, she immediately points at Balzagar as being the one that, uh, must have thrown her to the wolves. And, uh, it turns out that no, he was the last person, uh, of all of
[01:15:37] them that still supported, uh, Iarian. It was only when she chose to put her handmaiden to, uh, to the, um, the gallows that, uh, he realized, oh, hang on a second. Maybe she is hiding in plain sight, uh, here, how, you know, it, it, it was that thing, as I said, you know, she turned on her whole family. She sacrificed all of them. She turned on all of her friends to go along with Farazan and his, his cohort. So how could she possibly switch
[01:16:02] backsides to the faithful? Uh, so I really love that. That's how it's played out in this episode. And we have, again, if you're going to steal from the best deal from game of Thrones, we have, uh, Iarian, um, not wanting to give up the rest of her, her people. So she takes a, uh, a long, uh, walk off a short balcony. Yeah, no, exactly. I mean, and, and after a very, very tense and really excellent confrontation between, um, you know, Farazan, Kemen, uh, and,
[01:16:32] uh, uh, Balsagar, um, you know, she's really is trying to maintain, um, her role. Yeah. And ultimately it, it, it transpires that Farazan, you know, it's like, don't lie to me, you know, enough of the games really. Um, and there's no sense that she, I mean, they want her to come out with the truth and to stop, um, lying, you know, and he kind of says, we will make you the most loyal
[01:16:58] and devoted Kingsman ever, whether that's by choice or by, uh, fear and, um, or force. Yeah. And, uh, she kind of says, Il Sildur, I'm sorry. And he thinks that she's about to sort of blurt all the secrets out. Instead, she walks towards the balcony, um, and throws herself off. I think,
[01:17:22] you know, where it sort of moves it on from Game of Thrones in particular is that, you know, this is Iari and we've seen her meet up with Isildur earlier in the episode and she's kind of actually blaming the state of Numenor on her. She goes, Numenor is like this because of me. Um, and, you know, Isildur and her are trying to sort of, you know, work for the betterment of the
[01:17:51] faithful. Exactly. But Isildur having managed to contact, uh, Elendil through the palantir sees her body, uh, as she's looking up at him and really has to hold, uh, his emotions together here at the end, which I thought was really, really, um, kind of quite a poignant scene. It was, yeah. It reminded me of the story from the Bible, the gardens of Gethsemane where, uh, Peter has to deny his knowledge of, of Jesus three times. Um, yeah. Yeah. So it reminded me of
[01:18:20] that moment with, uh, with Isildur being asked, does he know the woman who's dead on the ground? And he has to deny the knowledge of his own sister who's bleeding out. Um, just thought it was really well played. Yeah. It was, it was really, um, yeah, really sort of full on, I think as, as a moment. And one, I mean, yeah, cause you've kind of been like by the end of season two, you're really disliking E.R. And here five years later, okay. We haven't seen the transformation and the reasons
[01:18:50] why in four, but you probably see all the genesis of it in season two. Definitely. Um, uh. Having to work alongside Kevin. Well, yes, exactly. Um, but you know, here then you see that she is trying to sort of help. Uh, and so I think it makes it really poignant here. So, um, yeah, I mean this, the whole Numenorean thing, I think, like I said at the start, it just felt much more
[01:19:14] grander. They feel much more embedded in the world. And maybe that's because of the plans of, of Farazhan to build this armada and this army to take down Sauron. Um, so yeah, I, I really, really, um, kind of enjoyed, um, this whole thing with the Numenoreans and I felt it just got a little bit deeper into them and more integrated into, uh, the, the world of Middle
[01:19:43] Earth. Yeah. Yeah. Without a doubt. So much looking forward to how this plays out as we get through the rest of the season. It's a, it's a fascinating story. Lots of mentions of things, uh, there about, um, you know, going to the West and the, the, uh, and the fair shores of Numenor, that that's where they're going to, uh, conduct their purge, uh, the safe zone effectively, this place where all of the, uh, the people are being ushered to safety, you know, even a
[01:20:10] sealed or says to, uh, Iari and, you know, he could get her out there and send her to the Western shores, you know? Um, it does feel like, you know, that the, the way Lord of the Rings ended with, uh, Gandalf and, and Frodo going off into the West, you know, the West seems to be this place where people go for safety. Uh, it is a different place of course, because Numenor is just an island, uh, an island, uh, before you get to the Grey Havens, but, uh, just mentions of those, uh, seem like there are terms within the book Lord of the Rings that are terms of safety, the havens,
[01:20:40] the, the, uh, the shores and, uh, and off to the West. So, um, just that they would go there rather than trying to purge the faithful from the city of Numenor, they're going to go out to where they believe they're safest and take them out there. And we hear Kemen is the one that gets the job to do that. If he does that, he will then become the heir to the throne of Numenor. So, uh, so Kemen is being sent out there by Farazhan, uh, as his, as his next
[01:21:05] mission after he went to Middle Earth and, uh, Middle Earth and helped, uh, conquer, uh, those two lands for the Numenorians. So yeah, I'll say conquer, he just walked in and said, you are now responsible for, uh, feeding our, our war machine, uh, effectively. But, uh, yeah, that's, uh, that's just something to mention there. Uh, any other notes, any other thoughts that we haven't talked about in this episode? Um, the only one from me is really about the absence of Gandalf, but Sauron is very much aware of him. So,
[01:21:35] um, I think when he has converted Camel, the fairest of the nine of Rune, um, to being one of the Naznagal, Camel, uh, does say, uh, about there is this one person that sort of, um, is constantly, um, rebelling and against the, the rule of the, the dark wizard, uh, and the, the men are, of Rune,
[01:22:01] and that is Gandalf. Um, and he's like, you know, Sauron says he is absolutely aware of Gandalf, which is an interesting, uh, little from Sauron. Yes. He says, I will take care of him myself. Yes. Um, it's on Sauron's, uh, yeah, it's on him to take care of Gandalf. It's on his agenda. Uh, the other one is just, uh, with Gil, uh, Gil-Galad and Serdan, uh, in Lindon. Yeah.
[01:22:26] Um, and that's where that they can see that Rune will be the next battlefront, but they kind of say that they can't, um, withstand such an onslaught from these hundreds of thousands of horsemen. Yeah. And it seems as though the battle or, or the war is very much closer to Lindon than it is to Rivendell. Yes. Um, here. So I, I think Lindon as well is possibly, uh, like, uh, uh,
[01:22:53] Reggion from, uh, the end of season two is very much more under threat from this war. Yes. Uh, I guess it is the seat of the King, so it would be more advantageous for Sauron to crush it, uh, and possibly take Gil-Galad as well. Yeah. But yeah, it's really just another little interesting, um, note from me. Excellent. Excellent. That is it for our chat all about the first two episodes. We've got loads more to go, including two more episodes this week to chat
[01:23:22] about for Rings of Power. But overall, John, did you enjoy the two premiere episodes of Lord of the Rings, the Rings of Power season three? Yeah, I did. I mean, I, I love, um, entering this world of Middle-earth. I just think it's really, really good. Um, I think for me, for episode one, Marnouk, I'd give it five, uh, medium to well-done orcs out of five. Um, just really enjoyed getting back
[01:23:47] into this world. It was nicely, the, that's kind of the, the, the five years later thing was done really well and it really set up the, the Nasna goal, which is what you want in this episode when you're teasing the nine rings for men and what they become in terms of the ring wraiths. Uh, you want to see that start to play out. And I think the juiciest part of that is Theo. Um, I, I think
[01:24:12] how that then progressed in episode two, just so good. And for me, the, the gift of men, uh, episode two, I'd give it five Numenorean highboards out of five, um, just purely for Iarian and a triple Salco off the balcony. She was fabulous in this episode. Yeah. It was just really nicely done. Lots of intrigue. We, we've, um, you know, come to hear about the havens in the West for the faithful,
[01:24:39] the Bay of Elros. Again, another part of Numenor where Muriel were, was hiding, you know, this, that secret refuge of the faithful. Yeah. And, um, I, I just think yet again, I love moving between the dwarves, the elves, the, the men now Mordor, uh, and as well, the other, uh, realms of men that
[01:25:04] Sauron still has to conquer. I mean, at this count, what, I think we have four of them in place, or three definitely in place, Theo on the table, possibly the fourth. So there is another five, uh, rings, um, that Sauron has to offer to others. Yeah. So yeah. Interesting. Exactly. Exactly. So yeah, absolutely loved, um, these first two episodes. Excellent. Let's get onto a little bit
[01:25:32] of feedback that we got from our wonderful fellow ringers. Um, we got an email in from coffee and vodka on episode one. He says, greetings fellow strategizing defenders. This is a major jump moving from the comic book that was vision quest to the tome that is the rings. Most of my interest fell to Mamouk from his bold entrance to the intrigue he brings with his meeting of King Duren. I can't imagine a double cross knowing the outcome of it all, but again, intriguing all the same.
[01:25:58] The elven politics are as tedious as ever, but more than compensated by Theo's further dive into evil that should have been apparent long before. Galadriel's ennui, Thrain's probable machinations, Camul and his force of a hundred thousand, and of course the return of Gandalf, a wonderfully dense return to the lands of Middle-earth. Off to the next one. And I can't imagine how you'll cover these without a two hour podcast per episode for all the events. Have fun, John. 5.5 ringing in horsements,
[01:26:27] love, royal love triangles, and ram horn solos out of five. Peace and take care. Coffee and vodka. Excellent stuff. Um, I'm absolutely loving it at the moment. Uh, thanks, but I, I guess we've, we've taken it as a, uh, quite a nice little pace so far. Um, we will have, uh, another two to do and then another two to do. So yes, we'll see by the end of it, but, uh, but, uh, but the good news
[01:26:54] is we're just about to hit the two hour mark and that's for two episodes. So that's too bad. Yes. Uh, I think, uh, this feels like our very own Wagnerian ring cycle, uh, for the rings of power. Um, and you know, I think that's what a three day opera or something like that. So I, I guess, uh, we'll see by the end of episode eight, but so far absolutely loving it because it's just so good
[01:27:17] to sort of delve into, um, this world and I totally with you real dense opener really brings you up to speed. Um, and some really good sort of through lines happening and intrigue starting. So yeah, absolutely loving, uh, this first episode. Yeah, definitely. Uh, coffee vodka also shared, uh, his thoughts on episode two as well. Yeah. He said, greetings,
[01:27:41] fellow self-defenestrating defenders. $60 million per episode seems almost sacrilegious to just say good episode me like, especially when being pretty much wall to wall tragedy like is a bit of a stretch more than anything. This rich tapestry of gloom, doom, and sadness is more appreciated for its pitch perfect detail in everything from costuming, set design, writing, special effects, acting,
[01:28:09] and everything really. Here we are back in Numenor following the fight between capital gains and faith, and it's not looking great for the latter. Although that initial sweep into the city of the parade is gorgeous. Asealdor remains the great hero, though there's at least one lady-in-waiting who might contest that. In the meantime, Theo might not be evil, but a plant by the good guys as Thrain is for
[01:28:34] the baddies. At least we can be somewhat sure that Monuk is part of a long con for Sauron to get hold of Galadriel's ring. And Asealdor's magic face time is somehow part of Farazhan's plan to take out the faithful, maybe. Again, so much intrigue about the only thing we can be sure of is Iaren is out of the
[01:28:57] espionage business. True. This season is making my head hurt, but in a good way. Five splattered spies, righteous gemstones, and bulging harbors out of five. Peace and take care. Coffee and vodka. Bulging harbors indeed. Yes, there's a lot of wood in that harbor for sure. A lot of floating wood,
[01:29:22] most definitely. Totally agree. There's some really great detailing through here. Again, like you say, I think Monuk, the long con, the red herring, what's going on there for these? Theo possibly working as a plan for the good guys. Yeah, but equally, I think the intrigue, as you point out, around what is going to happen to Theo. I mean, I do think for Theo,
[01:29:47] if he does turn, that makes so much sense to me. Despite Arande's best attempts, it has been sort of knackered and undermined by Kemen coming into the mix, which I think literally everything would. I even think Farazhan is a fool to sort of start talking about, you know, Kemen being his successor,
[01:30:13] because I think you bring Kemen in, it's just gonna, you just know he's not got the right balance to be a good kind of king. Oh, he'd be horrible. Absolutely horrible to the people and absolutely horrible to everybody around him just to get what he wants, basically. Yeah, exactly. So I think, yeah, totally agree around all this different intrigue and lots of question marks still over what is potentially going to happen through this. So yeah, totally with you there, coffee and vodka.
[01:30:43] Yeah, absolutely. Thanks so much, coffee and vodka for your thoughts. If you want to send in any of your thoughts to us, you can email us to feedback at tvpodcastindustries.com or pop on over to our Facebook group at facebook.com slash groups slash tvpodcastindustries. You can also join us over on our Discord details, which are in the show notes right here. We'll be back next time with the next two episodes in The Lord of the Rings, The Rings of Power season three, episode three, The Secret Fire, and episode four, Gundabad. Looking forward to chatting all about them on the podcast here.
[01:31:13] Thanks so much for joining us. We'll talk to you again next time. Yeah, thank you so much, fellow ringers, for joining us for these first two episodes and our discussion of those. Until the next two, keep watching, keep listening, and of course, don't stray far from the path. Bye. Bye.

